9708/23

Economics 9708/23October/November 2015

Cambridge AS Level · AS Level Data Response and Essays · worked solutions for every part, with the mark scheme

4
questions
40
marks
90
minutes

Topics Balance of Payments · Exchange Rates · Protectionism · International Trade and Comparative Advantage · Economic Systems · Market Equilibrium and the Price Mechanism · +6 more

Q1Balance of PaymentsProtectionismInternational Trade and Comparative AdvantageExchange RatesFree sample

EU agreement ‘biggest deal Canada has ever made’

Canada and the European Union (EU) signed the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA), a free trade deal that will eliminate 98% of all tariffs, and many barriers on trade, investment and labour mobility. Canadian manufacturers, investors and service providers will have access to the 500 million people in the EU, where the total value of production approaches 17 trillion Canadian dollars (C$17 trillion) a year. A study estimates that the duty-free access of Canada’s seafood, timber, manufacturing, agriculture and mineral industries to the EU will generate around C$12 billion in the Canadian economy and create about 80 000 new Canadian jobs.

Tariffs on imports from Europe of clothing, cheese, wine, dairy products and many other items would be removed. However, CETA could take two years to come into effect, as it requires the agreement of all EU members and the approval of Canada’s provinces.

Canadian dairy farmers are against the agreement. They remain in favour of protection from foreign cheese producers and claim that European cheese will be dumped in the Canadian market. Canadian cheese producers argue that the industry is able to produce high-quality products for Canadian consumers but now this growing industry will face direct competition from cheaper, subsidised European cheese producers. Canadian cheese producers could indeed face difficulties, but the Government would provide compensation to address the negative effects of the agreement on the Canadian dairy industry.

But others are optimistic about the agreement, as it will allow Canadian beef and grain to gain new access to European markets. The vice-president of the Canadian Cattlemen’s Association is also hopeful about the new agreement and believes that Canadian beef will be in ‘strong demand’ in the EU. Canadian producers will be able to sell an additional 50 000 tonnes of beef.

CETA’s website claims that under the agreement ‘Canada will now be one of the few developed countries in the world to have a guaranteed preferential access to more than 800 million consumers in the world’s two largest economies, the EU and the United States’.

Source: CTV News 2013, with files adapted from The Canadian Press

Table 1: Canada’s current account of the balance of payments 2008–2012, C$millions

20082009201020112012
Total receipts648 105511 855555 594619 460629 007
Total payments646 197557 605614 013667 926691 222

Table 2: Canada’s trade in goods: principal trading areas – seasonally adjusted, current C$millions

December 2012December 2013
Total exports38 61939 722
US28 57630 014
EU3 0282 640
Total imports38 63541 381
US24 37527 138
EU3 2573 385
Balance of trade in goods-16-1 659
(a)

Compare Canada’s current account balance in 2012 with its balance in 2008.

2M
(b)

With the help of a diagram, explain how the removal of tariffs on EU goods imported into Canada would affect their price and quantity.

4M
(c)

How would you decide whether Canada’s cheese producers should be protected from competition from EU cheese producers?

4M
(d)

Explain, using the theory of comparative advantage, how it is possible for consumers in both the EU and the Canadian economy to benefit from the movement towards free trade.

4M
(e)

Evaluate any further information that would help you to assess the economic impact of Canada’s trade agreement with the EU.

6M

The rest of this paper

3 more questions
  • Q2Economic Systems · Market Equilibrium and the Price Mechanism · Factors of Production · Production Possibility Curves · Economic Growth20M
  • Q3Classification of Goods and Services · Methods of Government Intervention in Markets20M
  • Q4Price Stability · Exchange Rates · Balance of Payments20M
Loading the full paper…