Physics 9702/31 — May/June 2017
Cambridge AS Level · Advanced Practical Skills · worked solutions for every part, with the mark scheme
Topics Manipulation, Measurement and Observation · Presentation of Data and Observations · Analysis, Conclusions and Evaluation
In this experiment, you will investigate an electrical circuit.
(a) Set up the circuit shown in Fig. 1.1.
The distance between the crocodile clips should be approximately .
Measure and record .
= ______
Answer
Measure with a metre rule.
Example (to nearest ):
x = 40.0 cm (example)
Background Concept
A length measurement should be taken with an instrument of suitable resolution (here, a metre rule). You must record the value to match the instrument’s smallest sensible division (typically on a standard metre rule), and you should read the scale without parallax error.
Understanding the Question
You are asked to measure the separation between the two crocodile clips on the wire, which should be about . The required response is a recorded value of .
Approach
- Align the metre rule with the wire.
- Read the positions of the two clip contact points on the wire.
- Calculate as the difference between the two position readings.
- Record to an appropriate precision.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Identify the exact contact points where each crocodile clip touches the wire (not the outer edge of the clip).
- Read the position of each contact point on the metre rule at eye level.
- Compute the separation:
- Record the result to the nearest (or the smallest clear division available).
Key Takeaways
- Measure between the correct points.
- Use a difference of two readings to reduce zero/end errors.
- Record with suitable precision.
Common Mistakes
- Measuring from the ends of the crocodile clips rather than the contact points.
- Parallax error from viewing the scale at an angle.
- Writing too many decimal places (false precision) or too few (loss of precision).
Things to Be Careful About
- Ensure the clips are firmly attached and not slipping along the wire.
- Keep the metre rule parallel to the wire and note the unit used ( or ) consistently for later graphing.
Close the switch.
Answer
Close the switch.
Switch closed
Background Concept
Closing a switch completes the circuit so current can flow. In practical work, you often keep the switch open except when taking readings to reduce heating of components (which can change resistances).
Understanding the Question
This step instructs you to complete the circuit so that the ammeter can show a steady current for reading .
Approach
Close the switch only when you are ready to take the ammeter reading.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- With the circuit correctly connected, closing the switch completes the loop.
- Current then flows through the ammeter, producing a reading.
Key Takeaways
- Close the switch to take readings; open it between readings to reduce heating.
Common Mistakes
- Leaving the switch closed for long periods, causing the wire/resistor to warm up and change current.
Things to Be Careful About
- Ensure connections are secure before closing the switch.
- If the ammeter reading is off-scale, open the switch immediately and change range.
Record the ammeter reading .
= ______
Answer
Record the current from the ammeter.
Example:
I1 = 0.35 A (example)
Background Concept
An ammeter measures current and must be connected in series. The reading should be taken on a suitable range to avoid overloading and to give good resolution. Record the value with an appropriate number of decimal places based on the meter’s resolution.
Understanding the Question
With the circuit in the Fig. 1.1 configuration and the switch closed, you must read and record the ammeter current as .
Approach
- Choose a safe range first (highest range), then reduce if needed for better precision.
- Wait briefly for the reading to settle.
- Record with unit .
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- If the ammeter is analogue, identify the correct scale and multiply by any range factor.
- If it is digital, read directly from the display.
- Record the reading, e.g.
(Your value will depend on your circuit and .)
Key Takeaways
- Correct connection (series) and correct range are essential.
- Record current with unit and sensible precision.
Common Mistakes
- Using the wrong range factor on an analogue meter.
- Forgetting the unit.
- Reading the scale from an angle (parallax) on analogue meters.
Things to Be Careful About
- Heating of the wire changes resistance and therefore the current; take the reading promptly after closing the switch.
- Ensure the ammeter reads zero (or note any zero error) before starting.
Open the switch.
Answer
Open the switch.
Switch opened
Background Concept
Opening the switch breaks the circuit so current stops flowing. This reduces heating of the wire/resistor, which helps keep conditions consistent for subsequent readings.
Understanding the Question
After recording , you are instructed to open the switch before making changes or taking the next set of readings.
Approach
Open the switch immediately after taking the reading.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- With the switch opened, the current becomes zero.
- This prevents further temperature rise in the wire and helps improve repeatability.
Key Takeaways
- Open the switch between readings to minimise systematic changes.
Common Mistakes
- Leaving the circuit energised while adjusting crocodile clips.
Things to Be Careful About
- If using a power supply, avoid short circuits when repositioning clips; keeping the switch open reduces risk.
Connect an additional lead L to the circuit as shown in Fig. 1.2.
Answer
Connect the additional lead exactly as in Fig. 1.2 (between the stated junctions).
Lead L connected as in Fig. 1.2
Background Concept
In circuit practicals, altering the circuit configuration changes the total resistance and therefore the current. Correctly connecting leads to the intended junctions is crucial; a wrong connection can create an unintended short circuit or open circuit.
Understanding the Question
You must add an extra lead to change the circuit from the Fig. 1.1 arrangement to the Fig. 1.2 arrangement. The key skill is correctly following the diagram and connecting to the correct nodes.
Approach
- Locate the two junctions indicated in Fig. 1.2.
- Connect one end of lead to the first junction and the other end to the second junction.
- Ensure all other components remain as in Fig. 1.1.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Identify junctions (nodes) rather than components: junctions are where wires/components meet.
- With the switch open, attach lead firmly so that it makes good electrical contact.
- Check visually that the circuit now matches Fig. 1.2 before closing the switch.
Key Takeaways
- Always connect based on junctions in the circuit diagram.
- Keep the switch open while rewiring.
Common Mistakes
- Attaching lead to the wrong side of a component (wrong node).
- Creating a short circuit by connecting across the power supply or bypassing the ammeter.
Things to Be Careful About
- Ensure crocodile clips are not touching each other or other conductive parts.
- Poor contacts introduce extra resistance and can affect .
Close the switch.
Answer
Close the switch.
Switch closed
Background Concept
Closing the switch completes the (modified) circuit so that current flows and the ammeter can display .
Understanding the Question
With lead connected (Fig. 1.2), you must now energise the circuit to measure .
Approach
Close the switch only when ready to read the ammeter.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Close switch to allow current to flow.
- Wait for a steady reading.
Key Takeaways
- Consistent procedure improves reliability.
Common Mistakes
- Leaving the switch closed too long, causing heating.
Things to Be Careful About
- If the reading is much larger than before, open the switch and increase the ammeter range.
Record the ammeter reading .
= ______
Answer
Record the current from the ammeter.
Example:
I2 = 0.42 A (example)
Background Concept
The ammeter measures the total current in the series part of the circuit. Changing the circuit (by adding ) changes the current, so is generally different from .
Understanding the Question
With the switch closed and lead connected, you must read and record the new ammeter current as .
Approach
As for : choose a suitable range, wait for a stable reading, and record with unit.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Confirm the ammeter is still in series and not bypassed.
- Read the current and record it, e.g.
(Your value will depend on your circuit and .)
Key Takeaways
- Record measurements consistently and clearly.
Common Mistakes
- Reading the wrong scale or range.
- Omitting the unit.
Things to Be Careful About
- Take the reading promptly to reduce the effect of temperature rise in the wire.
Open the switch.
Answer
Open the switch.
Switch opened
Background Concept
Opening the switch stops the current, helping to keep the wire temperature (and therefore resistance) as constant as possible between readings.
Understanding the Question
After measuring , you must open the switch before disconnecting .
Approach
Open the switch immediately after reading the ammeter.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Break the circuit by opening the switch.
- Then it is safe to alter the circuit connections.
Key Takeaways
- Open switch before rewiring.
Common Mistakes
- Removing while the switch is closed.
Things to Be Careful About
- Avoid accidental short circuits when leads are moved.
Remove L. The circuit is now as shown in Fig. 1.1.
Answer
Remove lead so the circuit returns to Fig. 1.1.
Lead L removed
Background Concept
To obtain paired readings for the same , you must switch between the two circuit configurations in a controlled way. Returning to the original configuration ensures the next reading is taken under the same circuit conditions as before.
Understanding the Question
You are instructed to remove so the circuit is again as in Fig. 1.1, ready for the next reading of at a new value of .
Approach
With the switch open, disconnect lead and check the remaining circuit matches Fig. 1.1.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Ensure no current flows (switch open).
- Disconnect lead from both junctions.
- Inspect the circuit: only the original connections in Fig. 1.1 remain.
Key Takeaways
- Resetting correctly prevents mixing configurations.
Common Mistakes
- Forgetting to remove , leading to incorrect values for later readings.
Things to Be Careful About
- Keep connections consistent; do not move crocodile clips unless you are changing deliberately.
Increase and repeat (b) and (c) until you have six sets of readings of , and .
Record your values in a table. Include values of in your table.
Answer
Obtain six sets of readings for , and over an increased range of , and calculate for each set.
Example of a suitable table:
Table of six readings with x, I1, I2 and I2/I1 (example shown)
Background Concept
Good experimental data must be (i) sufficiently numerous, (ii) spread over a suitable range of the independent variable, and (iii) clearly presented. A results table should include raw measurements (here , , ) and any calculated quantities required by the question (here the ratio ).
Table conventions in Cambridge practical papers:
- One table containing all results.
- Clear column headings with quantity and unit, e.g. , .
- Consistent decimal places/significant figures within each column.
Understanding the Question
You must increase the clip separation and, for each new , repeat the procedures in (b) and (c) to obtain paired currents (Fig. 1.1) and (Fig. 1.2). You need six sets of and must also calculate and record .
Approach
- Choose at least six values of that are reasonably spaced (e.g. every ) and cover a good range.
- For each :
- measure and record ,
- measure with the original circuit,
- add lead and measure ,
- open the switch between readings.
- Compute for each row and record it to a sensible number of significant figures.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Pick a sequence such as to .
- For each , take and promptly after closing the switch to reduce heating effects.
- Calculate the ratio for each row:
- Example for the first row:
- Keep the ratio to (typically) 2 or 3 significant figures, consistent across the ratio column.
Key Takeaways
- Collect enough data points (six) across a range of .
- Present data clearly in one table with headings and units.
- Calculate and include required derived quantities.
Common Mistakes
- Fewer than six sets of readings.
- Missing units in headings (e.g. writing just rather than ).
- Inconsistent decimal places within a column.
- Arithmetic errors when calculating .
Things to Be Careful About
- Use the same unit for throughout (if you use in the table, use on the graph).
- Avoid heating: open the switch between readings and do not leave current flowing.
- Ensure is the clip separation, not the position of a single clip.
Plot a graph of on the -axis against on the -axis.
Answer
Plot on the -axis against on the -axis, with axes labelled (including units for ) and points plotted accurately using a suitable scale.
Graph of I2/I1 (y) against x (x-axis) plotted
Background Concept
A graph is used to test a relationship and to obtain constants from the gradient and intercept. Good graph technique earns marks for:
- correct choice of axes,
- clear labels with units,
- sensible scales (use at least half of the grid in both directions),
- accurate plotting.
Understanding the Question
You must plot a graph with and on the horizontal axis. The data come from your table in (d).
Approach
- Horizontal axis: (use the same unit as your table, commonly ).
- Vertical axis: (dimensionless).
- Choose scales so the plotted points occupy a large area of the grid.
- Plot all six points clearly.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Draw axes and label:
- (or ),
- .
- Choose a scale such as per on the -axis (example) and a scale on the -axis that spreads the points.
- Plot each point using small crosses.
Key Takeaways
- Correct labelling and sensible scaling are essential.
Common Mistakes
- Swapping axes (plotting on -axis).
- Missing units for .
- Using awkward scales (e.g. 3 squares = 7 units) that reduce accuracy.
Things to Be Careful About
- has no unit; do not invent one.
- Plot points carefully; large blobs instead of fine crosses reduce accuracy when drawing a best-fit line.
Draw the straight line of best fit.
Answer
Draw a single straight line of best fit through the plotted points (balanced with roughly equal scatter above and below).
Straight line of best fit drawn
Background Concept
A best-fit line represents the overall trend of data when random uncertainties cause scatter. For a linear relationship, you should draw a straight line that is ‘balanced’—not forced through every point.
Understanding the Question
After plotting against , you must draw the straight line that best represents the trend.
Approach
- Use a ruler.
- Aim for approximately equal numbers of points above and below the line.
- Do not join point-to-point.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Place the ruler so the line passes through the central region of the plotted points.
- Check that the line is not overly influenced by one outlier.
- Draw a thin, clear straight line.
Key Takeaways
- Best-fit means representing the trend, not connecting dots.
Common Mistakes
- Forcing the line through the origin when not justified.
- Drawing a zig-zag line between points.
Things to Be Careful About
- If one point is clearly anomalous, the best-fit line should follow the other points; do not automatically force the line to pass through the anomaly.
Determine the gradient and -intercept of this line.
gradient = ______
-intercept = ______
Working
Using two well-separated points on the best-fit line (example): and ,
-intercept (from line / using ):
Answer
gradient = 8.8×10^-3 cm^-1, y-intercept = 0.85 (example)
Background Concept
For a straight-line graph, the gradient (slope) is
and the -intercept is the value of when . In practical graphs, you should use points on the best-fit line (not necessarily your original data points) and choose them far apart to reduce percentage uncertainty.
Units:
- Here is dimensionless.
- Therefore the gradient has units of (e.g. if is in cm).
Understanding the Question
You must find the gradient and -intercept of your best-fit straight line on the graph of (vertical axis) against (horizontal axis).
Approach
- Select two points on the drawn best-fit line that are widely separated.
- Read their coordinates accurately.
- Compute gradient using .
- Find intercept either by reading where the line crosses the -axis or by substituting into .
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Choose two points far apart (example values shown in the solution).
- Calculate:
- Because is in cm in this example, the gradient unit is .
- To obtain the intercept, rearrange :
and substitute one of the points.
- Alternatively, extend the line to and read the intercept directly (but calculating from is often more precise if reading is off the grid).
Key Takeaways
- Use the best-fit line, not a pair of raw points close together.
- Use a large triangle / widely spaced points to reduce uncertainty.
- Gradient units come from units divided by units.
Common Mistakes
- Using instead of .
- Using two neighbouring points, giving a large uncertainty in the gradient.
- Forgetting the gradient unit.
Things to Be Careful About
- Read coordinates carefully from the axes (especially if scales are not 1 per square).
- Keep consistent units: if you plotted in , your gradient must be in (unless you convert).
It is suggested that the quantities , and are related by the equation
where and are constants.
Using your answers in (e)(iii), determine values for and .
Give appropriate units.
= ______
= ______
Working
Given
Comparing with :
Using (e)(iii) (example):
Answer
P = gradient (cm^-1), Q = y-intercept (no unit) (example values shown)
Background Concept
A linear relationship has the form
where is the gradient and is the -intercept. If you plot against and obtain a straight line, you can identify constants in the equation by matching symbols to this standard form.
Units:
- is a ratio of two currents, so it is dimensionless.
- Therefore is dimensionless.
- Since must also be dimensionless, must have units of .
Understanding the Question
You are given
and asked to determine and using your gradient and intercept from (e)(iii), including appropriate units.
Approach
- Recognise that the graph in (e) was versus .
- Compare directly with .
- Set and .
- Assign units based on what you used for .
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- From the plotted variables:
- The equation matches , so:
- If was plotted in , then
and if was plotted in , then .
- has no unit because it is the value of the dimensionless ratio at .
Key Takeaways
- Constants in a straight-line model are read from gradient and intercept.
- Units come from the axes: dimensionless implies gradient has units of .
Common Mistakes
- Giving a unit (it should be dimensionless here).
- Giving the wrong unit for by forgetting whether was in or .
Things to Be Careful About
- Use your own measured gradient and intercept values from (e)(iii), not values from raw data points.
- State units explicitly for and state “no unit” (or omit units) for .
The rest of this paper
1 more questions- Q2Manipulation, Measurement and Observation · Analysis, Conclusions and Evaluation · Presentation of Data and Observations20M

