Physics 9702/33 — October/November 2015
Cambridge AS Level · Advanced Practical Skills · worked solutions for every part, with the mark scheme
Topics Manipulation, Measurement and Observation · Presentation of Data and Observations · Analysis, Conclusions and Evaluation
In this experiment, you will investigate the equilibrium of a wooden rod.
Set up the apparatus as shown in Fig. 1.1.
The mass should be . The string should be approximately half-way along the wooden rod. The spring should be horizontal.
Answer
Set up the rod, spring and string as in Fig. 1.1 with .
Adjust so that:
- the string is attached approximately halfway along the rod,
- the spring is horizontal,
- the rod is in equilibrium (steady, not slipping).
See working
Background Concept
This is an equilibrium practical: the rod is at rest, so it has no resultant force and no resultant moment (turning effect). For the measurements later to be meaningful, the apparatus must match the diagram and be in a steady equilibrium position.
Key practical ideas:
- Alignment matters: “spring horizontal” and “string horizontal” are geometric conditions that affect the relationship you will test.
- Repeatability depends on a stable set-up: if the rod slips, or the spring is not at the stated position, the readings of and will change.
Understanding the Question
You are instructed to set up the apparatus exactly as shown:
- a wooden rod rests against the bench making an angle with the bench,
- a horizontal spring is attached to the rod and to a clamp stand,
- a string is attached to the rod, passes over a hook at the top region, and supports a mass ,
- initially should be and the string should be about halfway along the rod.
This part is about getting a correct, workable set-up ready for accurate measurements in later parts.
Approach
- Assemble the hardware (bench, rod, clamp stand, spring, string, mass hanger).
- Set .
- Adjust the attachment point of the string to be roughly halfway along the rod.
- Adjust the clamp stand height/position so that the spring is horizontal.
- Ensure the rod is steady and does not slip before taking any measurements.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Place one end of the wooden rod on the bench and lean it so it makes a clear angle with the bench surface.
- Attach the spring between the rod and the clamp stand.
- Move the clamp stand (or change clamp height) until the spring is visibly horizontal (use the bench edge as a reference line).
- Tie/attach the string to the rod at approximately the midpoint of the rod (halfway along its length), then route it over the hook as shown and attach the mass hanger.
- Add masses until the total hanging mass is .
- Check that the rod and attachments are in equilibrium: no motion, no slipping at the contact point with the bench, and the spring and string remain taut.
Key Takeaways
- Correct set-up is essential: later calculations assume the spring/string are horizontal when stated.
- A stable equilibrium position improves accuracy and repeatability.
Common Mistakes
- Spring not actually horizontal (introduces systematic error in and the geometry).
- String not positioned roughly halfway along the rod (changes the torque balance and alters results).
- Rod slipping during readings (gives inconsistent and ).
Things to Be Careful About
- Ensure the mass value is the total hanging mass ( including any hanger if required by your lab’s convention).
- Ensure the spring is horizontal at the moment you take readings (not just “about horizontal”).
- Keep the bench contact point consistent; if the rod base moves, your geometry changes.
Measure and record the length of the coiled part of the spring.
= ______
Answer
Measure the coiled length of the spring with a ruler.
Example: (to the nearest ).
L = 6.2 cm
Background Concept
A length measurement should be:
- taken with an appropriate instrument (typically a mm-scale ruler),
- recorded to a precision consistent with the scale (usually to the nearest mm, i.e. ),
- clearly defined: here, the question specifies the coiled part of the spring, so you must not include any straight end hooks or connecting loops unless they are part of the coiled region.
Understanding the Question
You must measure , the length of the coiled part of the spring, while the apparatus is set up (with in part (a)). The value of will later be kept constant for different masses, so this initial measurement is important.
Approach
- Identify the start and end of the coiled section.
- Align a ruler parallel to the spring.
- Read at eye level to reduce parallax.
- Record with a unit and appropriate precision.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Place the ruler alongside the spring so that the ruler’s zero is aligned with one end of the coiled section.
- Read the position of the other end of the coiled section.
- Subtract if the zero cannot be aligned exactly.
- Record in cm to (or in mm to ).
Example recording:
Key Takeaways
- Measure the correct feature (coiled part only).
- Record to appropriate resolution with units.
Common Mistakes
- Measuring the entire spring including loops/hooks.
- Reading from an angle (parallax error).
- Writing a value with inappropriate precision (e.g. when a mm scale was used).
Things to Be Careful About
- Keep the spring straight and horizontal while measuring.
- If the spring is slightly stretched, ensure you still measure the coiled section end-to-end consistently in each trial.
Measure and record the height of the loop of the spring above the bench.
= ______
Answer
Measure the vertical height of the spring loop above the bench.
Example: (to the nearest ).
h = 10.5 cm
Background Concept
A height is a vertical distance from a reference level (here, the bench surface). If you measure along a slanted line, you do not get the true height. In practical work, a set square (or measuring from a vertical ruler) helps ensure the measurement is vertical.
Understanding the Question
You must measure , defined as the height of the loop (attachment point) of the spring above the bench.
- Reference: the bench surface.
- Point: the spring loop/attachment point at the rod.
Approach
- Use a ruler (or metre rule) held vertically with its zero at the bench surface.
- Ensure the reading is taken at the level of the loop using a set square (horizontal sight line).
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Position a metre rule vertically with its zero on the bench.
- Bring a set square (or another ruler) horizontally from the spring loop to meet the vertical scale.
- Read the vertical scale at the intersection.
- Record to the nearest mm (or ).
Example:
Key Takeaways
- Heights must be measured vertically from the correct reference surface.
- Use alignment aids to reduce parallax and angular errors.
Common Mistakes
- Measuring from the floor instead of from the bench.
- Measuring along the rod/spring instead of vertically.
- Guessing the height without aligning to the loop level.
Things to Be Careful About
- Take the reading at eye level to avoid parallax.
- Make sure you measure the height of the loop (exact point specified), not the clamp or a different part of the spring.
Measure and record the angle between the wooden rod and the bench.
= ______
Answer
Measure the angle between the rod and the bench using a protractor.
Example: .
θ = 52°
Background Concept
An angle measurement is only meaningful if you measure the angle between the correct two straight lines.
Here, is the angle between the rod and the bench:
- one line is along the rod,
- the other is along the bench surface (a horizontal line).
Understanding the Question
You must record in degrees. This angle will be used later in calculating , so a reasonable precision (typically nearest degree) is expected.
Approach
- Use a protractor.
- Align the protractor’s baseline with the bench (horizontal).
- Align the centre at the contact point (or use an extended straight edge along the rod).
- Read where the rod line crosses the protractor scale.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Place a straight edge along the rod to define a clear line.
- Place the protractor with its origin at the rod’s base point on the bench.
- Ensure the line is parallel to the bench.
- Read the angle up to the rod line.
Example:
Key Takeaways
- Angles depend on correct alignment; small misalignment can change noticeably.
Common Mistakes
- Measuring the complementary angle (e.g. between rod and vertical rather than rod and horizontal).
- Not aligning the baseline with the bench.
- Reading the wrong protractor scale (inner vs outer).
Things to Be Careful About
- Keep the rod steady while reading.
- Record as an integer number of degrees unless your protractor clearly supports half-degrees.
Change mass to .
Adjust the position of the spring and string so that the length is the same as in (b)(i) and the string is horizontal.
Repeat (b)(ii) and (b)(iii).
= ______
= ______
Answer
Change to . Adjust spring and string so that is the same as in (b)(i) and the string is horizontal.
Example readings:
h = 11.7 cm, θ = 56°
Background Concept
In practical investigations, you often vary one quantity (here ) while keeping another fixed (here the spring’s coiled length ). This control is vital so that any change in the measured geometry ( and ) is due to the intended change in , not because the spring extension changed.
Also, the instruction “string is horizontal” defines a specific geometry; if the string slopes, you introduce a systematic error because the forces/geometry are no longer the intended ones.
Understanding the Question
You must:
- Change the mass from to .
- Adjust the apparatus so that:
- stays the same as your earlier value,
- the string is horizontal.
- Measure and record new values of and .
Approach
- Replace the mass.
- Adjust the clamp stand position/height and the string attachment point until the spring returns to the same coiled length as in (b)(i).
- Check the string is horizontal (use a ruler/bench edge for reference).
- Then measure and using the same methods as in (b)(ii) and (b)(iii).
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Add masses to make .
- Observe that the geometry changes; the spring length will generally change.
- Move the spring attachment/clamp stand so that the coiled length matches your recorded (measure and adjust until it agrees).
- Adjust the string attachment so the string is horizontal (compare against a horizontal reference line).
- Once stable, measure:
- as a vertical height above the bench,
- as the angle between rod and bench.
Example set of readings:
Key Takeaways
- This is controlled variation: change , keep fixed.
- Always re-check alignment conditions (horizontal spring/string) before reading instruments.
Common Mistakes
- Forgetting to reset to the original value.
- Taking readings before the string is properly horizontal.
- Measuring from the wrong reference (not the bench).
Things to Be Careful About
- Re-measure after adjustments; do not rely on appearance.
- Ensure the apparatus is not oscillating when you read and .
Copy your value of from (b)(i).
= ______
Answer
Copied from (b)(i):
Example: .
L = 6.2 cm
Background Concept
In many practicals a measured quantity is used as a control variable. Writing it again reduces the chance of accidentally using a different value later.
Understanding the Question
You are told to copy your previously measured (coiled spring length) so you can use it as the fixed value while collecting multiple data sets in (d)(ii).
Approach
Simply transfer the value exactly as recorded in (b)(i), keeping the same unit and precision.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
If your (b)(i) reading was, for example,
then write the same here.
Key Takeaways
- Consistency of the control variable is essential for valid results.
Common Mistakes
- Changing the number of decimal places or unit when copying.
- Copying the wrong length (e.g. total spring length instead of coiled length).
Things to Be Careful About
- Keep exactly the same during later adjustments; this copied value is the target each time.
Change and repeat (b)(ii) and (b)(iii) until you have six sets of values of , and .
For each value of , adjust the position of the spring and string so that is the same as in (d)(i) and the spring is horizontal.
Include your values from (b) and (c).
Also include values of in your table.
Answer
Take six sets of readings of , and (including the and cases), keeping constant and the spring horizontal each time.
Record all results in one table with headings and units, and calculate for each set.
Example (illustrative):
| 40 | 8.7 | 48 | 13.0 |
| 50 | 9.6 | 50 | 15.0 |
| 60 | 10.5 | 52 | 17.0 |
| 70 | 11.2 | 54 | 19.0 |
| 80 | 11.7 | 56 | 21.0 |
| 90 | 12.2 | 58 | 23.0 |
See working
Background Concept
A good data table in Paper 3 is assessed on:
- Sufficient data: at least six sets over a sensible range of the independent variable.
- Clear headings: each column labelled with the quantity and unit, e.g. .
- Consistent precision: similar decimal places/precision within a column.
- Correct calculated quantities: derived values computed correctly from the measured values.
Here you are also told to calculate:
Since is dimensionless, has the same unit as .
Understanding the Question
You must build a table containing six sets of:
- (changed each run),
- (measured),
- (measured),
and the calculated quantity .
For each new you must adjust the apparatus so that:
- is the same as in (d)(i),
- the spring is horizontal.
You must include your earlier results from (b) and (c).
Approach
- Choose six values of spanning a reasonable range (including and ).
- For each :
- adjust until matches the fixed value,
- check spring horizontal,
- measure and .
- Calculate for each row.
- Present everything in one neat table with units and consistent precision.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Pick masses such as (any sensible range with six values is acceptable).
- For each mass:
- ensure the spring coiled length equals your fixed value (re-measure to confirm),
- measure vertically from the bench,
- measure between rod and bench.
- Compute :
- calculate (calculator in degree mode),
- divide by .
Example calculation for one row (illustrative): if and ,
Key Takeaways
- Use enough readings and a good range of .
- Keep control variables constant ( and spring horizontal) to make the test valid.
- Present raw and derived data clearly with units and consistent precision.
Common Mistakes
- Fewer than six sets of results.
- Missing units in headings (e.g. writing just instead of ).
- Inconsistent decimal places (e.g. mixing and without reason).
- Calculating instead of .
Things to Be Careful About
- Ensure calculator is in degrees for .
- Quote to a sensible number of significant figures (usually matching ).
- Do not change between runs; this is a key control.
Plot a graph of on the -axis against on the -axis.
Answer
Plot (y-axis) against (x-axis).
Axes labels (example):
- -axis:
- -axis:
Use a suitable scale and plot all six points accurately.
See working
Background Concept
A good physics graph should:
- have correctly labelled axes with units,
- use a sensible scale (not cramped; typically use at least half the grid in each direction),
- have accurately plotted points (fine pencil, small crosses or dots),
- match the instruction for which quantity goes on which axis.
Understanding the Question
You are told exactly what to plot:
- vertical axis: ,
- horizontal axis: .
You should use your calculated values from the table in (d)(ii).
Approach
- Decide the range of and from your table.
- Choose convenient scales (e.g. 10 g per large square; 2 cm per large square, etc.) that spread the data.
- Label each axis with both the symbol/expression and its unit.
- Plot each point carefully.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Mark axes and label:
- or (depending on what you used in the table),
- (or / m).
- Choose scales so the smallest and largest values fit with good spread.
- Plot the six points from your table.
Key Takeaways
- Correct graph choice and correct axis labelling are easy marks.
- Using the full grid improves accuracy when finding gradient and intercept.
Common Mistakes
- Swapping axes (plotting on the y-axis).
- Missing units or writing units incorrectly in the labels.
- Using an awkward scale (e.g. 3 g per square) that makes plotting error-prone.
Things to Be Careful About
- Plot , not just .
- Keep consistent units: if is in cm, then is also in cm.
Draw the straight line of best fit.
Answer
Draw a single straight line of best fit through the plotted points (not point-to-point).
See working
Background Concept
A best-fit line represents the overall trend in the data. For experimental results there will be scatter, so the best-fit line should be positioned so that the points are approximately balanced above and below the line.
Understanding the Question
You have plotted against . You must now draw the straight line of best fit.
Approach
- Use a ruler.
- Draw one straight line that follows the trend.
- Ensure it is not forced through every point or through the origin unless the data clearly supports it.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Visually assess the general linear trend.
- Place a ruler so that there are roughly equal numbers of points above and below the line (and similar average distances).
- Draw a thin, continuous straight line across the whole data range.
Key Takeaways
- Best-fit is not “join-the-dots”.
- Do not assume the line must pass through .
Common Mistakes
- Connecting points with zig-zag segments.
- Forcing the line through an outlier.
- Forcing the line through the origin without evidence.
Things to Be Careful About
- Extend the line far enough to allow a reliable intercept reading.
- Keep the line thin so that gradient/intercept readings are not ambiguous.
Determine the gradient and -intercept of this line.
gradient = ______
-intercept = ______
Working
Using two points on the best-fit line, e.g. and :
-intercept at :
Answer
gradient
-intercept
gradient = 0.20 cm g^-1, y-intercept = 5.0 cm
Background Concept
For a straight-line graph, the gradient and y-intercept describe the line:
- Gradient:
- y-intercept: the value of when .
In practical graphs, you should use two points on the best-fit line, not necessarily two experimental points, and choose them far apart to reduce percentage reading uncertainty.
Understanding the Question
You must extract two values from your straight line:
- the gradient,
- the y-intercept.
These will be used in part (f) to determine constants and .
Approach
- Pick two widely separated points on the drawn best-fit line (read their coordinates).
- Compute gradient using .
- Read the y-intercept by extending the best-fit line to and reading .
- Include correct units.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Choose two points on the line far apart.
- Read coordinates carefully, matching the axis scales.
- Calculate:
- Determine intercept by reading where the line crosses the y-axis.
Illustrative example (your values depend on your graph):
Key Takeaways
- Use points on the best-fit line and make the triangle large.
- Gradient is always “change in y divided by change in x”.
- Include units: gradient has units of (y-units)/(x-units).
Common Mistakes
- Using two nearby points, giving a large percentage uncertainty.
- Swapping and (calculating ).
- Using two data points that are not on the best-fit line.
- Forgetting units, or using inconsistent units (e.g. in g but quoting gradient per kg).
Things to Be Careful About
- If your axes are and then your units will change (e.g. gradient in ).
- Read intercept from the best-fit line extended to the y-axis, not from the first plotted point.
The quantities , and are related by the equation
where and are constants.
Using your answers in (e)(iii), determine the values of and .
Give appropriate units.
= ______
= ______
Working
Given
Comparing with for a graph of against :
Using (e)(iii):
Answer
A = 0.20 cm g^-1, B = 5.0 cm
Background Concept
If a relationship is linear:
then a graph of against is a straight line with:
- gradient ,
- y-intercept .
Here,
This is already in linear form if you treat as and as .
Units:
- has the same unit as (since is dimensionless).
- Therefore has the same unit as .
- has units:
So if is in cm and is in g, then is in .
Understanding the Question
You are asked to determine and using your gradient and y-intercept from (e)(iii), and to include appropriate units.
Approach
- Recognise that the plotted graph is exactly vs for the linear equation.
- Set gradient and y-intercept.
- Assign units from the graph axes.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
From the instruction in (e)(i), the graph is:
- -axis:
- -axis:
So the equation becomes:
Therefore:
Using example values from (e)(iii):
Key Takeaways
- When the equation is already linear, constants come directly from gradient and intercept.
- Units come from the axes: gradient has units (y-units)/(x-units).
Common Mistakes
- Swapping and .
- Giving no units.
- Using inconsistent units (e.g. graph plotted with in g but quoting in ).
Things to Be Careful About
- If you plotted in kg instead of g, your numerical value for would change by a factor of .
- Quote and to a reasonable number of significant figures consistent with your graph reading accuracy.
The rest of this paper
1 more questions- Q2Manipulation, Measurement and Observation · Presentation of Data and Observations · Analysis, Conclusions and Evaluation20M

