Physics 9702/36 — October/November 2011
Cambridge AS Level · Advanced Practical Skills · worked solutions for every part, with the mark scheme
Topics Manipulation, Measurement and Observation · Presentation of Data and Observations · Analysis, Conclusions and Evaluation
You may not need to use all of the materials provided.
In this experiment, you will investigate the equilibrium of a mass and pulley system.
The apparatus has been set up in an arrangement similar to that shown in Fig. 1.1.
Answer
Apparatus as shown: string over two pulleys with two end hangers; central knot between pulleys. Height is measured vertically from the bench to the central knot (with the system at rest).
Apparatus identified; H is the vertical height of the central knot above the bench.
Background Concept
In practical mechanics, a diagram is used to define what is being measured and the reference level for measurements. A “height above the bench” is a vertical distance measured from the bench surface (reference level) to the point of interest.
In pulley-string systems, you must also ensure the system is stationary before taking readings so the geometry (and hence the measured heights) is well-defined.
Understanding the Question
You are told the apparatus is already set up similar to Fig. 1.1. The key point is to recognise:
- two pulleys fixed to a horizontal bar,
- a single string passing over both pulleys,
- mass hangers at the two ends,
- a central knot/loop in the middle of the string.
The quantity is defined as the vertical distance from the bench surface up to the central knot.
Approach
Use the diagram to:
- identify the correct point to measure to (the central knot),
- identify the correct reference level (the bench surface),
- ensure the system is at rest so the knot position is stable.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Locate the central knot between the pulleys.
- Visualise a vertical line from the bench surface up to the knot: that is .
- Ensure the string and hangers are not swinging; wait for equilibrium.
Key Takeaways
- Always state the reference level for heights.
- Ensure equilibrium (no motion) before measuring a position.
Common Mistakes
- Measuring to the pulley axle or to the horizontal bar instead of the knot.
- Measuring along the string (a slanted distance) instead of vertically.
- Taking readings while the knot is still oscillating.
Things to Be Careful About
- Parallax: your eye should be level with the knot when reading a rule.
- The bench surface must be the same reference level used throughout the experiment.
Measure and record the height of the central knot above the bench.
= ______
Answer
Measure with a metre rule held vertically (eye level with the knot).
Example:
Example: H = 0.650 m
Background Concept
A height measurement is a vertical displacement between two levels. A metre rule typically has 1 mm smallest divisions, so a sensible recording precision is to the nearest 1 mm, i.e. uncertainty, and record to .
Understanding the Question
You must measure the height of the central knot above the bench in the initial arrangement (before the central mass is added). The answer space shows the unit is metres, so you should record in .
Approach
- Place/hold the rule vertically with its zero at the bench surface.
- Read the value at the central knot.
- Record in metres to an appropriate number of decimal places.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Align the metre rule so it is vertical and close to the knot.
- Make sure the zero of the rule corresponds to the bench surface (not the clamp base or some other point).
- Bring your eye level with the knot to avoid parallax.
- Read and record with consistent precision (e.g. ).
Key Takeaways
- Measure vertically from the stated reference level.
- Record to the resolution of the measuring instrument.
Common Mistakes
- Writing the unit as cm even though the answer line specifies metres.
- Recording too few decimal places (e.g. ) when a mm-scale rule was used.
- Measuring from the floor instead of the bench.
Things to Be Careful About
- If the knot is thick, decide a consistent point (e.g. the centre of the knot) and use it every time.
- Ensure the system is stationary when reading.
Suspend the mass hanger from the central loop as shown in Fig. 1.2.
Answer
Suspend the mass hanger from the central loop/knot so it hangs freely and allow the system to come to rest before taking readings of and .
Central mass hanger attached and allowed to reach equilibrium.
Background Concept
In equilibrium experiments, the key requirement is a stable, repeatable geometry. Adding a load at the central knot changes the shape of the string and lowers the knot to a new position (height ). Measurements are only meaningful once the system is stationary.
Understanding the Question
You must attach a third hanger of mass at the central knot/loop as in Fig. 1.2. This creates a new height for the knot.
Approach
- Attach the hanger securely at the central loop.
- Ensure it does not touch the bench or other parts of the apparatus.
- Wait for oscillations to stop.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Hook the central hanger onto the loop at the knot.
- Check the string sits correctly in the pulley grooves.
- If the knot swings, wait until it becomes still; only then measure .
Key Takeaways
- Equilibrium readings require the system to be at rest.
- The hanger must hang freely for the force to be vertical.
Common Mistakes
- Taking while the knot is still moving.
- The central hanger rubbing against a stand, changing the effective forces.
Things to Be Careful About
- Make sure the knot/loop does not slip along the string when the mass is added.
- Ensure both end masses remain suspended and the string stays taut.
Record the central suspended mass .
= ______
Answer
Record the total central suspended mass (hanger + any added masses) in .
Example:
Example: m = 0.100 kg
Background Concept
Masses in practical work are usually supplied as slotted masses labelled in grams. The exam requires SI units, so you should convert to kilograms:
The total suspended mass is the mass of the hanger plus all masses added to it.
Understanding the Question
You must write down the value of for the mass hanging from the central loop. This is then varied later, so it must be recorded accurately.
Approach
- Add up all components of the central load.
- Convert to .
- Record with sensible precision (typically to if masses are in steps).
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- If the hanger is, for example, and you add , the total is .
- Convert: .
- Record clearly with unit.
Key Takeaways
- Always use the total suspended mass.
- Convert g to kg correctly.
Common Mistakes
- Recording only the added masses and forgetting the hanger mass.
- Leaving the answer in grams.
Things to Be Careful About
- Keep consistent increments in so you get a good spread of data later.
- Ensure the labelled masses are secure so they do not fall during measurements.
Measure and record the height of the central knot above the bench, as shown in Fig. 1.2.
= ______
Answer
With the central mass attached and the system at rest, measure vertically from the bench to the central knot.
Example:
Example: h = 0.580 m
Background Concept
When a load changes, the system moves to a new equilibrium. The measured quantity is a vertical height, so it must be taken in the same way as to make the subtraction meaningful.
Random uncertainty can be reduced by taking repeat readings and averaging.
Understanding the Question
After attaching the central mass, the knot moves down. You must measure and record the new height above the bench.
Approach
- Wait until motion stops.
- Measure vertically from the same reference level (bench) to the same point (knot).
- Record to the same precision as .
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Ensure the central hanger is not swinging.
- Place the rule vertically close to the knot.
- Read at eye level.
- If time allows, read twice and take the mean.
Key Takeaways
- Consistency between and measurements is crucial.
- Repeat readings help reliability.
Common Mistakes
- Measuring to a different point on the knot than was used for .
- Recording to a different precision than .
Things to Be Careful About
- If the bench is not level or the rule cannot touch the bench directly, use a fixed reference (e.g. a block of known height) consistently for both and and correct appropriately.
Calculate the deflection , where .
= ______
Working
Example:
Answer
Example: y = 0.070 m
Background Concept
A deflection is a change in position. Here the deflection is defined explicitly as:
So is positive because adding the central mass makes the knot move down, meaning is smaller than .
For subtraction, the decimal places in the result should match the least precise of the two readings.
Understanding the Question
You are given (initial height) and have measured (new height). You must calculate the deflection and record it in metres.
Approach
- Substitute your measured values into .
- Keep units consistent (both in metres).
- Record to an appropriate precision.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Using the example values:
- , .
- Subtract:
The unit stays as metres because it is a difference of two lengths.
Key Takeaways
- Derived quantities must be calculated using the defined formula.
- Units and precision must be consistent with the measurements.
Common Mistakes
- Doing and getting a negative deflection.
- Mixing units (e.g. in cm and in m).
Things to Be Careful About
- If your values of and are close, may be small; keep enough decimal places so is not rounded to zero.
Change by adding masses to the hanger suspended from the central loop and repeat (c)(ii), (c)(iii) and (c)(iv) until you have six sets of values for , and .
Include in your table of results values for and .
Answer
Obtain six different values of (using a wide range). For each measure , calculate , then calculate and record and .
Record all values in one table with headings (quantity and unit), e.g.
Example calculation (for one row):
Six-row results table including m, h, y, 1/y^2 and 1/m^2 with correct headings/units (values student-dependent).
Background Concept
Good experimental data must be:
- sufficient in quantity (enough data points to identify a trend),
- wide in range (so the graph has a reliable gradient),
- recorded clearly (single table, correct headings, units),
- processed correctly (derived quantities calculated for every row).
Here, the experiment ultimately needs a straight-line plot of against , so you must compute these two derived columns.
Understanding the Question
You must vary the central mass and repeat measurements until you have six sets of , and . You must also include and in the same table.
Approach
- Choose six values of spanning a good range (e.g. equal steps).
- For each :
- wait for equilibrium,
- measure ,
- compute ,
- compute and .
- Tabulate everything with correct units and consistent precision.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Choosing the range: If all values are too similar, changes little, making the gradient uncertain. Use the full set of masses to spread .
- Measuring reliably: take repeat readings of if possible and average to reduce random error.
- Calculating :
- Calculating the derived columns:
Use your calculator carefully with brackets.
- Table conventions: headings should be in the form “quantity / unit” and all entries in a column should have consistent decimal places where appropriate.
Key Takeaways
- Six well-spaced data points improve the reliability of a straight-line graph.
- A clear table with correct units and consistent precision is essential.
- Derived quantities must be calculated for every row.
Common Mistakes
- Only taking a narrow range of values.
- Forgetting to include and columns.
- Writing headings without units, or writing units in the data cells inconsistently.
- Calculator error: using as is fine mathematically, but missing brackets can cause mistakes.
Things to Be Careful About
- If is small, becomes very large; keep enough significant figures in so rounding does not dominate.
- Ensure is in before calculating , otherwise your x-axis values (and gradient units) will be wrong.
- Keep the same throughout; if the apparatus shifts, re-measure and restart so the dataset is consistent.
Plot a graph of on the -axis against on the -axis.
Answer
Plot (units ) on the -axis against (units ) on the -axis.
- Use a scale that uses at least half of each axis.
- Label each axis with quantity and unit.
- Plot all six points accurately.
Graph of 1/y^2 (y-axis) against 1/m^2 (x-axis), correctly labelled and scaled (student-dependent).
Background Concept
A good graph allows you to determine relationships and constants reliably. Cambridge marking typically rewards:
- correct choice of axes,
- clear axis labels including units,
- sensible scales (not cramped, not awkward),
- accurate plotting of points.
Understanding the Question
You have calculated and for six data sets. You must plot:
- vertical axis:
- horizontal axis:
Approach
- Decide suitable axis ranges using your minimum and maximum values.
- Choose scales that spread the points over much of the graph paper.
- Plot each pair as a small, neat cross.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- From your table, identify the smallest and largest and .
- Choose scales (e.g. 1 large square = some convenient value) so points span most of each axis.
- Label axes as:
- on x-axis
- on y-axis
- Plot all six points accurately.
Key Takeaways
- Axis labels must include units.
- Good scaling reduces uncertainty in gradient and intercept.
Common Mistakes
- Swapping axes (plotting on y-axis).
- Missing units on axis labels.
- Using a scale that compresses points into a small region.
Things to Be Careful About
- Do not force the axes to start at zero unless it helps; choose ranges based on your data.
- Plotting errors often come from reading the wrong column or misplacing decimal points; double-check each coordinate.
Draw the straight line of best fit.
Answer
Draw a single straight line of best fit through the plotted points (not point-to-point), with approximately equal scatter of points above and below the line.
Straight line of best fit drawn.
Background Concept
A best-fit line represents the overall trend of data with random scatter. For a linear relationship, the best-fit line should:
- be straight,
- pass through the central trend of the points,
- have roughly equal numbers (or equal overall spread) of points on either side.
Understanding the Question
After plotting the points, you must draw the straight line that best represents the relationship between and .
Approach
- Use a ruler.
- Do not connect the points one by one.
- Ignore small scatter and aim for an overall balance.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Place the ruler so the line passes through the “middle” of the cluster.
- Adjust so the vertical deviations (residuals) look balanced.
- Draw the line across most of the graph area to help with intercept readings.
Key Takeaways
- The best-fit line is about the trend, not exact passage through every point.
Common Mistakes
- Joining successive points instead of drawing a best-fit line.
- Forcing the line through the origin when the data do not support it.
Things to Be Careful About
- If one point is clearly anomalous, you normally still draw the best-fit line for the main trend; do not “bend” the line to include it.
Determine the gradient and -intercept of this line.
gradient = ______
-intercept = ______
Working
Use a large triangle on the best-fit line:
Read -intercept where .
Example (from a typical graph):
Answer
gradient = (from your graph)
-intercept = (from your graph)
Gradient and y-intercept read from the best-fit line (student-dependent).
Background Concept
For a straight-line graph, the gradient and intercept come from the general form:
where:
- is the gradient (slope),
- is the y-intercept (value of when ).
For experimental graphs, gradients should be found using a large triangle on the best-fit line (not between two adjacent data points), because this reduces the percentage uncertainty.
Understanding the Question
Your axes are:
- (units ),
- (units ).
You must determine:
- the gradient of the straight best-fit line,
- the y-intercept (the value of when ).
Approach
- Choose two well-separated points on the best-fit line.
- Read their coordinates accurately.
- Compute:
- Read the intercept from where the best-fit line crosses the -axis.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Pick two points far apart on the drawn line (not necessarily actual plotted points), e.g. one near the left and one near the right.
- Suppose these points have coordinates and .
- Compute changes:
- Then:
- Units of gradient:
- The y-intercept is the value of at . If the line crosses below zero, the intercept is negative.
Key Takeaways
- Use the best-fit line, not point-to-point.
- Use a large triangle to reduce uncertainty.
- Gradient units come from (y-units)/(x-units).
Common Mistakes
- Calculating (inverting the gradient).
- Using two nearby points so small reading errors give a large gradient error.
- Reading the intercept from a plotted point rather than where the line crosses the axis.
Things to Be Careful About
- Always use the same axis variables: here and .
- Extend the best-fit line far enough to reach the y-axis cleanly so the intercept can be read.
- Keep enough significant figures when calculating the gradient so rounding does not dominate.
The relationship between and is
where and are constants.
Using your answers from (e)(iii), determine the values of and .
Give appropriate units.
= ______
= ______
Working
Given:
Let and , so:
Hence:
Units:
Answer
p = gradient; q = −(y-intercept); units: p in kg^2 m^-2, q in m^-2.
Background Concept
If you plot a graph and obtain a straight line, you can extract constants by comparing your graph to the straight-line form:
The gradient is the coefficient of , and the y-intercept is the constant term.
Units of constants can be found from the units of and :
Understanding the Question
You are given the relationship:
You have already plotted (vertical) against (horizontal) and found the gradient and y-intercept. You must now use those to determine and , including units.
Approach
- Identify what your graph uses as and .
- Rewrite the given relationship to match .
- Read off from the gradient.
- Use the sign of the intercept to find .
- Determine units from the plotted variables.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Define:
Then the given equation becomes:
Comparing with :
- gradient corresponds to ,
- intercept corresponds to .
So:
and
If your y-intercept is negative (common here), then becomes positive.
Units:
- is a length in , so has units .
- is a mass in , so has units .
Therefore
and
Key Takeaways
- Match your graph variables to and before comparing with .
- Watch the sign: intercept equals .
- Units of gradient and intercept follow directly from axis units.
Common Mistakes
- Stating equals the y-intercept (missing the minus sign).
- Giving the wrong units by forgetting what was plotted on each axis.
- Using (mass) and (gradient) interchangeably and getting confused; keep symbols distinct.
Things to Be Careful About
- If your intercept is positive, would be negative: accept what your graph shows and apply consistently.
- Ensure you used in when calculating ; otherwise the numerical value (and hence ) will be wrong by a factor of if grams were used.
The rest of this paper
1 more questions- Q2Manipulation, Measurement and Observation · Presentation of Data and Observations · Analysis, Conclusions and Evaluation20M


