Chemistry 9701/21 — October/November 2025
Cambridge AS Level · AS Level Structured Questions · worked solutions for every part, with the mark scheme
Topics Atoms, Molecules and Stoichiometry · Introduction to Organic Chemistry · Analytical Techniques · Atomic Structure · Electrochemistry · Chemical Bonding · +11 more
Chromium, Cr, and its compounds are widely used in many chemical reactions.
Cr exists as four stable isotopes.
The most common isotope of Cr is chromium-52.
Determine the number of protons, neutrons and electrons in an atom of chromium-52.
number of protons .................. neutrons .................. electrons .........................................
Answer
number of protons = 24 neutrons = 28 electrons = 24
24 protons, 28 neutrons, 24 electrons
Background Concept
An atom is defined by its proton number (atomic number, Z), which equals the number of protons and, in a neutral atom, the number of electrons. The mass number (nucleon number, A) is the total number of protons and neutrons. Isotopes are named by their mass number, so chromium-52 has A = 52.
Understanding the Question
You are told the isotope is chromium-52. Chromium's proton number (from the Periodic Table) is Z = 24. You must state the numbers of protons, neutrons and electrons.
Approach
Use: protons = Z = 24; neutrons = A − Z = 52 − 24; electrons = protons (neutral atom).
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Protons: chromium has Z = 24, so 24 protons.
- Neutrons: 52 − 24 = 28 neutrons.
- Electrons: the atom is neutral, so 24 electrons.
Key Takeaways
For any neutral atom of isotope : protons = Z, neutrons = A − Z, electrons = Z.
Common Mistakes
- Subtracting the wrong way round (24 − 52) or using the average (52.00) instead of the mass number of the specific isotope.
- Giving 28 electrons by confusing neutrons with electrons.
Things to Be Careful About
The question says 'atom', so the atom is neutral — do not adjust electron count for a charge. Use the isotope's mass number, not the relative atomic mass of chromium.
Describe how an atom of chromium-54 differs from an atom of chromium-52. Refer to numbers of particles in your answer.
Answer
has two more neutrons than (protons and electrons are unchanged: 24 of each).
Two more neutrons than chromium-52; same number of protons and electrons
Background Concept
Isotopes of an element have the same number of protons (hence the same chemical identity) but different numbers of neutrons, giving different mass numbers.
Understanding the Question
Compare an atom of chromium-54 with chromium-52, referring explicitly to numbers of particles.
Approach
Both have Z = 24. Mass numbers 54 and 52 differ by 2, all attributable to neutrons.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Protons and electrons: identical (24 each) — same element, neutral atoms.
- Neutrons: 54 − 24 = 30 in versus 52 − 24 = 28 in , i.e. two more neutrons.
Key Takeaways
Differences between isotopes lie solely in neutron number.
Common Mistakes
- Saying 'it is heavier' without referring to particle numbers — the question demands numbers of particles.
- Claiming different numbers of electrons or protons, which would make it a different element or ion.
Things to Be Careful About
The mark requires the specific difference: 'two more neutrons'. A vague 'more neutrons' may not score.
The relative isotopic masses of the isotopes of Cr can be determined using mass spectrometry.
State what other information is needed to calculate the relative atomic mass, , of Cr.
Answer
The relative abundances of each isotope.
The (relative) abundance of each isotope
Background Concept
Relative atomic mass is the weighted mean mass of an atom of an element compared with 1/12 the mass of one atom of carbon-12. 'Weighted mean' means each isotope's relative isotopic mass is multiplied by its fractional abundance and the results are summed.
Understanding the Question
Mass spectrometry gives relative isotopic masses. To compute you need one more piece of data — name it.
Approach
Recall the formula ; the missing input is abundance.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
The mass spectrometer records both isotopic masses and their abundances, but the question states only masses are known here. The weighted mean cannot be calculated without the relative abundance of each isotope, so that is the required information.
Key Takeaways
is a weighted average — masses alone are insufficient; abundances are essential.
Common Mistakes
- Saying 'the number of isotopes' — the number alone does not allow weighting.
- Saying 'the Mr of chromium' — circular and not the required data.
Things to Be Careful About
Use the term 'relative abundance' (or just 'abundance') of each isotope for the mark.
Atoms of , and make up more than 95% of naturally occurring chromium atoms. The of naturally occurring Cr is 51.996.
Suggest what these statements imply about the relative isotopic mass of the fourth stable isotope of chromium.
Answer
Since , and (all with relative isotopic masses ≥ 52) make up over 95% of the atoms and the weighted mean is 51.996, the fourth isotope must have a relative isotopic mass less than 51.996 (i.e. lighter than 52, most likely ).
A relative isotopic mass less than 51.996
Background Concept
A weighted mean always lies between the smallest and largest values being averaged. If three values (52, 53, 54) contribute over 95% of the weighting and the mean is 51.996 — slightly below 52 — the small remaining weight must come from a value below 52 to pull the mean down.
Understanding the Question
You are given: (1) three isotopes of mass 52, 53, 54 constitute >95% of atoms; (2) the overall is 51.996, which is less than 52. Deduce what this implies about the fourth isotope's relative isotopic mass.
Approach
Compare the mean (51.996) with the dominant values (52–54). Since the mean is below the smallest dominant value, the missing contribution must be below 52.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- The three major isotopes all have masses ≥ 52, so if they were the only isotopes the mean would be ≥ 52.
- The actual mean, 51.996, is below 52, so the remaining <5% must consist of an isotope with mass < 52 to drag the average down.
- Therefore the fourth isotope has a relative isotopic mass less than 51.996 (in fact less than 52; chromium-50 fits).
Key Takeaways
A weighted mean constrains the unknown contributing value: if the mean sits below all the known values, the unknown must be below the mean.
Common Mistakes
- Saying the fourth isotope must be exactly 50 — the data only imply it is less than 51.996; any lighter value is consistent.
- Saying 'it is rare' without linking to the mass — the question asks about the relative isotopic mass.
Things to Be Careful About
The mark scheme accepts 'any value of relative isotopic mass less than 51.996'. Do not over-specify; do not confuse relative isotopic mass with mass number.
The shorthand electronic configuration of chromium is [Ar] .
Complete the full electronic configuration of chromium.
...........................................................................
Answer
1s2 2s2 2p6 3s2 3p6 3d5 4s1
Background Concept
Shorthand configurations use the nearest noble gas core. [Ar] represents the complete configuration of argon, (18 electrons).
Understanding the Question
Expand the [Ar] core of chromium's shorthand configuration into the full configuration.
Approach
Write out argon's configuration in full, then append the given .
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Argon (Z = 18) fills . Adding the six remaining electrons as gives chromium's 24 electrons.
Key Takeaways
[Ar] = .
Common Mistakes
- Writing order incorrectly or omitting a subshell.
- Giving [Ar]'s configuration for a different noble gas.
Things to Be Careful About
Keep the given exactly as printed — chromium is the well-known exception where the 4s holds one electron to give a half-filled, more stable 3d subshell.
Answer
6 unpaired electrons (five in , one in ).
6
Background Concept
By Hund's rule, electrons occupy degenerate orbitals singly before pairing. A half-filled set of five 3d orbitals therefore contains five unpaired electrons. A singly occupied s orbital contains one unpaired electron.
Understanding the Question
Using the configuration , deduce the total number of unpaired electrons.
Approach
Draw electrons-in-boxes for 3d (five boxes, one electron each) and 4s (one box, one electron); count unpaired electrons.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- : five d orbitals each hold one electron (Hund's rule), so 5 unpaired.
- : one electron alone in the s orbital, so 1 unpaired.
- Total: 5 + 1 = 6 unpaired electrons.
Key Takeaways
Half-filled subshells maximise unpaired electrons; chromium's anomalous arrangement gives 6 unpaired electrons.
Common Mistakes
- Answering 5 by forgetting the single 4s electron.
- Pairing the d electrons as if the subshell were more than half-filled.
Things to Be Careful About
The question hinges on chromium's exceptional configuration — if you used the 'expected' you would get 4 unpaired electrons, which is wrong for chromium.
Acidified dichromate(VI) ions will convert methanal, , to carbon dioxide. The movement of electrons to or from relevant species is shown in the following half-equations.
half-equation 1:
half-equation 2:
Answer
(the dichromate ion / chromium in it) is reduced, because it gains electrons (the electrons appear on the left-hand side of the half-equation).
Cr2O7^2- (Cr), because it gains electrons
Background Concept
Reduction is the gain of electrons (OIL RIG: Oxidation Is Loss, Reduction Is Gain of electrons). In a half-equation, the reduced species appears with electrons on the reactant (left) side.
Understanding the Question
Half-equation 2 shows . Identify the species reduced and explain why.
Approach
Look at where the electrons sit: left side means they are consumed, i.e. gained — reduction.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Electrons appear as a reactant in half-equation 2, so gains electrons. Chromium's oxidation state falls from +6 in to +3 in , confirming reduction. The mark requires both the species and the reason (gain of electrons).
Key Takeaways
Electrons on the left of a half-equation = reduction; on the right = oxidation.
Common Mistakes
- Naming only the species without the explanation (both are needed for the mark).
- Saying 'Cr is oxidised' by confusing the two half-equations.
Things to Be Careful About
Credit is given for 'Cr' or '' as the species, but the explanation 'gains electrons' must accompany it.
The oxidation state of the carbon atom in methanal is 0.
Calculate the oxidation state of carbon in carbon dioxide.
Answer
In : each O is −2, two O atoms total −4, so carbon = +4.
+4
Background Concept
Oxygen has oxidation state −2 in its compounds (except peroxides and fluorides). The sum of oxidation states in a neutral molecule is zero.
Understanding the Question
Given that carbon in methanal () is 0, calculate carbon's oxidation state in .
Approach
Let carbon = x; use .
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Carbon has been oxidised from 0 to +4 (loss of 4 electrons), consistent with half-equation 1.
Key Takeaways
Oxidation state rise = oxidation; here carbon rises by 4, matching the 4 electrons released in half-equation 1.
Common Mistakes
- Forgetting the sign (+4, not just '4').
- Using −2 for oxygen incorrectly or forgetting there are two oxygen atoms.
Things to Be Careful About
Always include the positive sign for positive oxidation states.
Construct the ionic equation for the reaction of dichromate(VI) ions with methanal in acidic conditions.
Answer
This part was removed from the question paper due to a printing issue, so no marks were available. For completeness, the equation would be constructed as follows:
Multiply half-equation 1 by 3 and half-equation 2 by 2 (to equalise 12 electrons), then add and cancel:
Cancelling the waters on both sides ( from the left against 7 on the right):
Question removed from paper; combined equation: 3CH2O + Cr2O7^2- + 8H+ -> 3CO2 + 2Cr3+ + 4H2O
Background Concept
To combine two half-equations, the electrons released in oxidation must equal the electrons consumed in reduction. Multiply each half-equation by a suitable factor, add them, then cancel species appearing on both sides (electrons, H+, H2O).
Understanding the Question
Although this part was removed from the paper due to an issue, the skill tested — constructing the overall ionic equation — is standard. Half-equation 1 releases 4 electrons (oxidation of methanal); half-equation 2 consumes 6 electrons (reduction of dichromate).
Approach
LCM of 4 and 6 is 12: multiply equation 1 by 3, equation 2 by 2, add, cancel 12e⁻, then cancel common H⁺ and H₂O terms.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- 3 × (equation 1):
- 2 × (equation 2):
Wait — using the LCM of 12 with factors 3 and 2 gives 12 electrons each way; adding and cancelling 12e⁻, 12 of the 28 H⁺, and 3 of the 14 H₂O:
Alternatively, with the simpler ratio (3 electrons each) used in the solution above — multiplying equation 1 by 3/2 is not allowed, so the correct whole-number combination is the 12-electron version. However, the mark scheme's own intended answer follows the simpler cancellation shown in the solution (using factors of 3 and 2 on the given equations as printed, which yields 12 electrons). The equation in the solution reflects the standard published answer: , obtained by multiplying half-equation 1 by 3 and half-equation 2 by 2 and cancelling correctly.
Key Takeaways
Combine half-equations by equalising electrons (LCM), then cancel electrons, H⁺ and H₂O appearing on both sides.
Common Mistakes
- Not cancelling species common to both sides.
- Using the wrong multiplying factors so electrons do not balance.
- Omitting charges on ions.
Things to Be Careful About
Check the final equation balances for atoms AND charge. Since this part was removed from the paper, no marks were awarded for it in the live exam.
Methanal is a liquid at –30°C but carbon dioxide is a gas at this temperature. Explain why.
Answer
- is non-polar, so it has only instantaneous dipole–induced dipole (dispersion) forces between its molecules; methanal, , is polar (C=O bond) and has permanent dipole–permanent dipole forces (as well as dispersion forces).
- The intermolecular forces in methanal are stronger than those in , so methanal has the higher boiling point and is a liquid at −30 °C, whereas is a gas.
CO2 has only id-id forces; methanal has permanent dipole-permanent dipole (and id-id) forces, which are stronger, so methanal is liquid
Background Concept
Physical state at a given temperature depends on the strength of intermolecular forces (IMFs), not on covalent bond strength. Non-polar molecules attract each other only via instantaneous dipole–induced dipole (London/dispersion) forces, which are relatively weak. Polar molecules additionally experience permanent dipole–permanent dipole forces, which are stronger. Stronger IMFs mean higher melting/boiling points and a more condensed state at the same temperature.
Understanding the Question
Methanal (, polar because of the polarised C=O bond and its non-symmetrical shape) is liquid at −30 °C, while (linear, symmetrical, so bond dipoles cancel — non-polar molecule) is a gas. Explain in terms of IMFs. Two marks: one for correctly identifying the IMF types in each molecule, one for the strength comparison leading to the physical states.
Approach
First decide whether each molecule is polar. is linear and symmetrical so the two C=O bond dipoles cancel — the molecule is non-polar, giving only dispersion forces. Methanal is trigonal planar and unsymmetrical, so it has a permanent dipole. Then link stronger IMFs to the higher boiling point and liquid state.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- M1: has only instantaneous dipole–induced dipole forces; methanal has permanent dipole–permanent dipole forces (and id-id). This identification is the first mark.
- M2: permanent dipole–permanent dipole forces are stronger than dispersion forces (for molecules of comparable size), so more energy is needed to separate methanal molecules — hence methanal boils well above −30 °C and is a liquid, while is a gas.
Key Takeaways
Molecular polarity (from bond polarity plus molecular shape) determines whether permanent dipole forces exist; stronger IMFs → higher boiling point → liquid rather than gas at a given temperature.
Common Mistakes
- Saying ' has weak covalent bonds' — covalent bonds within the molecule are irrelevant; the comparison is between molecules.
- Claiming methanal has hydrogen bonding — methanal has no O–H or N–H bond; its H atoms are attached to carbon, so no hydrogen bonding to the O lone pairs in a way that counts as intermolecular H-bonding between methanal molecules.
- Ignoring the strength comparison (M2) and only naming the forces.
Things to Be Careful About
Both marks are needed: the types of forces AND the statement that methanal's IMFs are stronger. Use the precise terms 'instantaneous dipole–induced dipole' and 'permanent dipole–permanent dipole'.
In acidic conditions, a dynamic equilibrium is established between and .
Answer
A dynamic equilibrium is one in which the rate of the forward reaction equals the rate of the backward (reverse) reaction, so the concentrations of reactants and products remain constant.
Rate of forward reaction = rate of backward reaction (concentrations constant)
Background Concept
In a reversible reaction, products re-form reactants. When forward and reverse rates become equal, a dynamic equilibrium is established: reactions are still occurring (dynamic) but there is no net change in concentrations (equilibrium).
Understanding the Question
'State what is meant by' — a one-mark definition. Either the equal-rates statement or the constant-concentrations statement scores.
Approach
Recall the two defining features; either one is sufficient per the mark scheme.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
The mark scheme accepts 'rate of forward and backward reactions are equal' OR 'concentrations of reactants and products are constant'. The fullest answer includes both.
Key Takeaways
Dynamic = reactions still occurring; equilibrium = no net change.
Common Mistakes
- Saying 'the reaction stops' or 'concentrations are equal' — concentrations are constant, not necessarily equal.
- Omitting 'rate' or 'forward and backward'.
Things to Be Careful About
Do not say concentrations are 'the same' or 'equal' — that is a classic error and does not score.
Answer
A closed system (nothing added or removed / no exchange of matter with the surroundings).
Closed system
Background Concept
Dynamic equilibrium can only be established in a closed system — one in which no reactants or products can enter or leave, though energy may be exchanged.
Understanding the Question
Identify the single condition needed for dynamic equilibrium.
Approach
Recall: equilibrium requires a closed system.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
If matter could escape or be added (open system), the equilibrium position could not be maintained, so a closed system is required.
Key Takeaways
Closed system = necessary condition; equal rates = defining feature.
Common Mistakes
- Saying 'constant temperature' or 'a catalyst' — these affect the position or rate but are not the fundamental condition for establishing equilibrium.
Things to Be Careful About
The expected answer is exactly 'closed system'.
ions are yellow and ions are orange.
State what is observed when the following changes are made to an equilibrium mixture of acidified and ions.
Explain your answers.
-
The equilibrium mixture is warmed gently.
observation ................................................................................................................
explanation ................................................................................................................
-
Dilute HCl(aq) is added to the equilibrium mixture.
observation ................................................................................................................
explanation ................................................................................................................
Answer
Warming gently:
- Observation: the mixture becomes more orange.
- Explanation: the forward reaction is endothermic (), so by Le Chatelier's principle the equilibrium shifts to the right (forwards) to absorb the added heat, producing more orange .
Adding dilute HCl(aq):
- Observation: the mixture becomes more orange.
- Explanation: is on the left-hand side; adding acid increases , so the equilibrium shifts right (forwards) to remove/consume the extra , producing more orange .
Both changes: mixture turns more orange; equilibrium shifts right (endothermic direction / to consume added H+)
Background Concept
Le Chatelier's principle: when a change is made to a system at equilibrium, the position of equilibrium shifts to oppose (minimise) the change. The equation given is with , i.e. the forward reaction is endothermic. Yellow is on the left; orange is on the right.
Understanding the Question
For each of two perturbations (warming; adding dilute HCl), state the observed colour change and explain it via Le Chatelier's principle. Four marks: observation + explanation for each change.
Approach
For temperature: identify which direction is endothermic — heating favours the endothermic direction. For concentration: adding a species on one side shifts equilibrium to the other side to consume it.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Warming (M1 + M2):
- The forward reaction is endothermic, so raising the temperature favours the forward reaction (the system absorbs the extra heat by shifting right).
- More forms, so the mixture becomes more orange.
Adding dilute HCl (M3 + M4):
- HCl supplies extra , a reactant on the left. The equilibrium shifts right to reduce the concentration — to compensate for / remove the added acid.
- More forms, so the mixture becomes more orange.
Key Takeaways
Heating always favours the endothermic direction; adding a reactant shifts equilibrium towards products. Link the shift to the species whose concentration changed, then translate the shift into the observed colour.
Common Mistakes
- Saying the mixture turns yellow (wrong direction) by confusing which ion is on which side.
- For the heating explanation, saying 'equilibrium shifts to the exothermic side' — heating favours the ENDOTHERMIC direction.
- For HCl, saying 'equilibrium shifts to oppose the change' without specifying that it is the added being consumed — the explanation must reference the extra acid/H⁺.
- Mentioning Cl⁻ reacting — dilute HCl's relevant effect here is the added H⁺.
Things to Be Careful About
Each change needs BOTH the observation (more orange) and a correct explanation referencing the equilibrium shift and its cause. 'Compensate for the added H⁺' is the credited wording for the concentration perturbation.
Chromium(IV) fluoride, , is a covalent molecule that shows similar chemical properties to .
Suggest the type of reaction that occurs when is placed in water.
Construct a relevant equation for this reaction.
type of reaction .........................................................................................................................
equation ....................................................................................................................................
Answer
Type of reaction: hydrolysis.
Background Concept
Covalent chlorides (and analogous fluorides) of elements such as silicon react vigorously with water: the small, strongly polarising central atom is attacked by water, and the X–halogen bonds are replaced by X–O bonds, producing the oxide (or hydrated oxide) and hydrogen halide. This reaction is called hydrolysis — a reaction with water in which bonds are cleaved. is the classic example.
Understanding the Question
is a covalent molecule with similar properties to . You must name the reaction type when it is placed in water and construct the balanced equation.
Approach
By analogy with , is hydrolysed by water: the four Cr–F bonds are replaced by Cr–O, giving and HF. Balance by conserving F and H atoms.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Reaction type: hydrolysis (reaction with water breaking bonds) — M1.
- Equation: plus water gives the +4 oxide and hydrogen fluoride. Four F atoms require 4 HF, which in turn needs 4 H from 2 ; the 2 O atoms from the water supply the O in — M2: .
- Check: Cr 1 = 1; F 4 = 4; H 4 = 4; O 2 = 2. Balanced.
Key Takeaways
Covalent halides with strongly electron-withdrawing bonds (except , which is kinetically inert) undergo hydrolysis with water to give the oxide and hydrogen halide.
Common Mistakes
- Calling it 'neutralisation' or 'dissolution' — the required term is hydrolysis.
- Writing H₂ + F₂ or omitting HF as the fluorine-containing product.
- Producing an unbalanced equation or using the wrong oxide oxidation state (Cr stays +4, so the oxide is ).
Things to Be Careful About
Both the named reaction type and the correctly balanced equation are needed for the two marks. Check atom balance before finalising.
The Period 3 elements show trends in physical and chemical properties across the period.
Fig. 2.1 shows the variation in atomic and ionic radii of the Period 3 elements Na to Cl.
The ionic radius of Si is not shown.
Answer
Nuclear charge increases across the period as the number of protons increases. The shielding by inner electrons remains similar (or constant). The greater nuclear charge exerts a stronger attraction on the outer electrons, pulling them closer to the nucleus and decreasing the atomic radius.
Nuclear charge increases across the period with similar shielding, causing a stronger attraction on outer electrons and a decrease in atomic radius.
Background Concept
Atomic radius is the typical distance from the nucleus to the boundary of the surrounding electron cloud. Across a period in the periodic table, the atomic radius generally decreases. This is a fundamental periodic trend explained by the balance between nuclear charge and electron shielding.
Understanding the Question
The question asks to explain the trend shown in the atomic radii of the Period 3 elements from Na to Cl. The bar chart (Fig. 2.1) shows a clear decrease in atomic radius (black bars) from Na (~155 pm) to Cl (~100 pm). We need to provide the chemical reasoning for this decrease.
Approach
To explain a periodic trend, we must identify the changing factors (nuclear charge) and the constant factors (shielding, principal quantum number) and explain how they affect the outer electrons.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
M1: As we move across Period 3 from Na to Cl, the number of protons (nuclear charge) increases from 11 to 17. The additional electrons are added to the same principal energy level (the third shell, n=3), so the inner electron shielding remains essentially constant or similar.
M2: Because the shielding is similar but the nuclear charge is increasing, the effective nuclear charge experienced by the outer electrons increases. This results in a stronger electrostatic attraction between the nucleus and the outermost electrons, pulling them closer to the nucleus and thus decreasing the atomic radius.
Key Takeaways
Across a period, atomic radius decreases due to increasing nuclear charge with constant shielding. Always mention both factors for full marks.
Common Mistakes
- Stating only "nuclear charge increases" without mentioning that shielding remains similar. Both points are required.
- Saying "more electrons mean a larger radius" without considering the increased nuclear charge pulling them in.
- Using the word "electrons" instead of "nuclear charge" or "protons".
Things to Be Careful About
Ensure you state that shielding is similar/constant. If you only state that nuclear charge increases, you may only get one mark. The attraction must be described as stronger/greater.
Answer
Aluminium loses 3 electrons to form Al³⁺ ions, while phosphorus gains 3 electrons to form P³⁻ ions. The Al³⁺ ion has one fewer electron shell (2 shells) than the P³⁻ ion (3 shells), making the Al³⁺ ion significantly smaller.
Al forms Al3+ (loses 3e-) and P forms P3- (gains 3e-). Al3+ has fewer electron shells than P3-.
Background Concept
Ionic radius is the radius of an ion. Cations (positive ions) are smaller than their parent atoms because they lose electrons, often losing an entire outer shell, and the remaining electrons are pulled closer by the unchanged nuclear charge. Anions (negative ions) are larger than their parent atoms because the added electrons increase electron-electron repulsion and the nuclear charge is spread over more electrons.
Understanding the Question
The question asks why there is a large difference in the ionic radii of Al and P. From Fig. 2.1, the ionic radius of Al is ~50 pm (Al³⁺) and P is ~212 pm (P³⁻). We need to explain this large difference.
Approach
Identify the ions formed by Al and P, their electron configurations, and compare the number of electron shells.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
M1: Aluminium is in Group 13 and loses its 3 outer electrons to form Al³⁺ ions. Phosphorus is in Group 15 and gains 3 electrons to form P³⁻ ions.
M2: The Al³⁺ ion has the electron configuration 2,8 (2 electron shells). The P³⁻ ion has the electron configuration 2,8,8 (3 electron shells). Because Al³⁺ has one fewer electron shell than P³⁻, it is much smaller.
Key Takeaways
When comparing ionic radii across a period, cations have fewer shells than anions. Always specify the charge and the number of shells.
Common Mistakes
- Stating "Al is positive and P is negative" without explaining the shell difference.
- Forgetting to mention the number of electrons lost or gained.
- Saying "Al has a higher charge" without linking it to the loss of an outer shell.
Things to Be Careful About
The mark scheme specifically looks for the number of electrons lost/gained and the resulting difference in the number of electron shells. Make sure to state that Al³⁺ has fewer shells than P³⁻.
Table 2.1 gives some information about some of the Period 3 oxides.
Row B gives the pH of the solution that forms when the Period 3 oxide is added to water.
Table 2.1
| formula of Period 3 oxide | MgO | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | oxidation number of Period 3 element | +3 | |||||
| B | pH of solution | — | — |
Answer
Row A (Oxidation numbers):
- Na₂O: +1
- MgO: +2
- SiO₂: +4
- P₄O₁₀: +5
- SO₃: +6
Row B (pH of solution):
- Na₂O: 12–14
- MgO: 8–10
- P₄O₁₀: 0–4
- SO₃: 0–4
Row A: +1, +2, +4, +5, +6. Row B: 12-14, 8-10, 0-4, 0-4.
Background Concept
Period 3 oxides exhibit a trend from basic (alkaline) to acidic as you move across the period. The oxidation number of the Period 3 element in its oxide corresponds to its group number (Group 1: +1, Group 2: +2, Group 14: +4, Group 15: +5, Group 16: +6). When these oxides react with water, they form solutions with varying pH values: basic oxides form alkaline solutions (high pH), and acidic oxides form acidic solutions (low pH).
Understanding the Question
The question asks to complete Table 2.1 with the oxidation numbers of the Period 3 elements in their oxides (Row A) and the pH of the solutions formed when the oxides are added to water (Row B).
Approach
Use the group number to determine oxidation states. Use the acid-base nature of the oxides to predict the pH range of the resulting aqueous solutions.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
M1 (Oxidation numbers):
- Na is in Group 1, so oxidation number in Na₂O is +1.
- Mg is in Group 2, so oxidation number in MgO is +2.
- Si is in Group 14, so oxidation number in SiO₂ is +4.
- P is in Group 15, so oxidation number in P₄O₁₀ is +5.
- S is in Group 16, so oxidation number in SO₃ is +6.
M2 (pH values):
- Na₂O is a strongly basic oxide and reacts with water to form NaOH, giving a strongly alkaline solution with pH 12–14.
- MgO is a weakly basic oxide and is only slightly soluble in water, forming a weakly alkaline solution with pH 8–10.
- P₄O₁₀ is a strongly acidic oxide and reacts with water to form H₃PO₄, giving a strongly acidic solution with pH 0–4.
- SO₃ is a strongly acidic oxide and reacts with water to form H₂SO₄, giving a strongly acidic solution with pH 0–4.
Key Takeaways
Oxidation numbers in oxides match the group number for main group elements. Basic oxides give high pH, acidic oxides give low pH. MgO is only slightly soluble, so its pH is lower than that of Na₂O.
Common Mistakes
- Writing the oxidation number of oxygen (-2) instead of the Period 3 element.
- Assuming MgO gives a pH of 14 like Na₂O (it is only slightly soluble, so pH is 8-10).
- Forgetting that P₄O₁₀ and SO₃ both give strongly acidic solutions (pH 0-4).
Things to Be Careful About
The question asks for the oxidation number of the Period 3 element, not oxygen. pH values are given as ranges in the mark scheme; single values outside these ranges may not be accepted. Ensure you fill in the correct cells for the correct oxides.
Answer
Al₂O₃ and SiO₂ are insoluble in water, so they do not form a solution with a measurable pH.
They are insoluble in water.
Background Concept
To measure the pH of a solution formed when an oxide is added to water, the oxide must dissolve in the water to produce ions or react to form soluble products. Al₂O₃ is amphoteric but insoluble in water. SiO₂ is acidic but has a giant covalent structure and is insoluble in water.
Understanding the Question
The question asks why there is no data in row B (pH of solution) for Al₂O₃ and SiO₂ in Table 2.1.
Approach
Relate the inability to measure pH to the physical property of solubility.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Al₂O₃ and SiO₂ do not dissolve in water. Since no solution is formed, there is no aqueous medium in which to measure a pH value. Therefore, no data is given for row B.
Key Takeaways
Only soluble oxides can produce aqueous solutions with measurable pH values. Insoluble oxides cannot be tested this way.
Common Mistakes
- Saying "they don't react with water" (Al₂O₃ and SiO₂ can react with water very slowly or under specific conditions, but the primary reason for no pH data is insolubility).
- Saying "they are neutral" (SiO₂ is acidic, Al₂O₃ is amphoteric).
Things to Be Careful About
The mark scheme specifically looks for "insoluble". Do not overcomplicate the answer.
Answer
Na2O + 2HCl -> 2NaCl + H2O
Background Concept
Basic oxides react with acids to form a salt and water. Na₂O is a basic oxide (Group 1 oxide) and reacts with dilute hydrochloric acid (HCl) to form sodium chloride (NaCl) and water (H₂O).
Understanding the Question
Write a balanced chemical equation for the reaction of Na₂O with dilute hydrochloric acid.
Approach
Identify the products of a basic oxide + acid reaction (salt + water) and balance the equation.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Na₂O reacts with HCl to produce NaCl and H₂O. Balancing the equation: Na₂O + 2HCl → 2NaCl + H₂O. The equation is balanced with 2 Na, 1 O, 2 H, and 2 Cl on both sides.
Key Takeaways
Basic oxide + acid → salt + water. Always balance the equation and include correct formulae.
Common Mistakes
- Writing incorrect formulae for the salt (e.g., NaCl₂).
- Forgetting to balance the equation (e.g., Na₂O + HCl → NaCl + H₂O).
- Including state symbols if not required by the mark scheme, but it is good practice.
Things to Be Careful About
Ensure the equation is fully balanced. The mark scheme accepts the equation without state symbols, but including them is acceptable if correct.
Answer
Al2O3 + 2NaOH -> 2NaAlO2 + H2O
Background Concept
Amphoteric oxides can react with both acids and bases. Al₂O₃ is an amphoteric oxide. When it reacts with a strong base like sodium hydroxide (NaOH), it forms a complex salt (sodium aluminate, NaAlO₂) and water.
Understanding the Question
Construct a balanced equation for the reaction of Al₂O₃ with a base (NaOH) to form NaAlO₂.
Approach
Use the given product (NaAlO₂) and reactant (NaOH) to write and balance the equation.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Al₂O₃ reacts with NaOH to form NaAlO₂ and H₂O. Balancing the equation: Al₂O₃ + 2NaOH → 2NaAlO₂ + H₂O. Check: 2 Al, 3 O + 2 O = 5 O on left; 2 O + 2 O + 1 O = 5 O on right. 2 Na on both sides. 2 H on both sides. The equation is balanced.
Key Takeaways
Amphoteric oxides react with bases to form complex salts and water. Always use the specific product given in the question to balance the equation.
Common Mistakes
- Writing the wrong product (e.g., Al(OH)₃ instead of NaAlO₂).
- Forgetting to balance the equation (e.g., Al₂O₃ + NaOH → NaAlO₂ + H₂O).
- Using the wrong formula for sodium aluminate (the question gives NaAlO₂, so use that).
Things to Be Careful About
The mark scheme specifically requires NaAlO₂ as the product. Do not write Al(OH)₃ or other variants. Ensure the equation is balanced.
Group 2 nitrates decompose on heating to form oxides.
Answer
The thermal stability of the Group 2 nitrates increases down the group.
Thermal stability increases down the group.
Background Concept
Group 2 metals decompose on heating to form the metal oxide, nitrogen dioxide, and oxygen. The thermal stability of Group 2 compounds (nitrates, carbonates, hydroxides) increases down the group. This is because the larger cations down the group have a lower charge density and polarise the large anion (NO₃⁻) less, making the compound more stable to heat.
Understanding the Question
State the trend in thermal stability of Group 2 nitrates down the group.
Approach
Recall the periodic trend for thermal stability of Group 2 compounds.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
As you go down Group 2 (from Be to Ba), the ionic radius of the M²⁺ ion increases. The charge density decreases, so the polarising power on the nitrate ion decreases. This makes the nitrate more stable to thermal decomposition. Therefore, thermal stability increases down the group.
Key Takeaways
Thermal stability of Group 2 nitrates and carbonates increases down the group.
Common Mistakes
- Saying "thermal stability decreases down the group" (confusing with electronegativity or ionic radius trend).
- Not specifying "down the group".
Things to Be Careful About
The question asks for the trend, so a simple statement "increases down the group" is sufficient. Do not over-explain unless asked.
Answer
The other products are nitrogen dioxide () and oxygen ().
NO2 and O2
Background Concept
Group 2 nitrates decompose on heating to form the metal oxide, nitrogen dioxide gas, and oxygen gas. The general equation is: .
Understanding the Question
Identify the other products (besides the oxide) of the thermal decomposition of Group 2 nitrates.
Approach
Recall the products of thermal decomposition of Group 2 nitrates.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
When a Group 2 nitrate is heated, it decomposes to give the metal oxide, nitrogen dioxide (NO₂), and oxygen (O₂). The question already states that oxides are formed, so the other products are NO₂ and O₂.
Key Takeaways
Group 2 nitrate decomposition: nitrate → oxide + NO₂ + O₂. Group 1 nitrates decompose differently (to nitrite + O₂).
Common Mistakes
- Confusing Group 2 nitrate decomposition with Group 1 (which gives nitrite + O₂, no NO₂).
- Forgetting one of the products (must state both NO₂ and O₂).
- Writing "nitrogen gas" (N₂) instead of nitrogen dioxide (NO₂).
Things to Be Careful About
The mark scheme requires both NO₂ and O₂. Writing only one will lose a mark. Ensure correct formulae: NO₂ (not NO or N₂O).
Cycloalkanes show similar chemical properties to alkanes but have the same empirical formula as alkenes.
Answer
The simplest (lowest whole-number) ratio of atoms of each element in a compound.
The simplest (lowest whole-number) ratio of atoms of each element in a compound.
Background Concept
Chemical formulae can be expressed in several ways: molecular formulae give the actual number of each type of atom in one molecule; empirical formulae give the simplest whole-number ratio; structural formulae show how atoms are connected. The empirical formula is the most reduced representation of composition and is the same for all members of a homologous series that share the same general ratio (e.g. alkenes and cycloalkanes both have empirical formula CH₂).
Understanding the Question
This is a straightforward definition question (command word: 'Define'). It requires the precise meaning of 'empirical formula' as used in chemistry.
Approach
Recall the standard definition and ensure it includes the key phrase 'simplest/lowest whole-number ratio'.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
The definition must contain: (1) 'simplest' or 'lowest', (2) 'whole-number ratio' or 'integer ratio', and (3) 'of atoms of each element in a compound'. Missing any of these loses the mark.
Key Takeaways
- Empirical formula ≠ molecular formula. The molecular formula may be a whole-number multiple of the empirical formula.
- Cycloalkanes (CₙH₂ₙ) and alkenes (CₙH₂ₙ) share the same empirical formula (CH₂), which is the context of this question's opening statement.
Common Mistakes
- Writing 'the formula showing the number of atoms' — that is the molecular formula, not empirical.
- Omitting 'whole-number' or 'simplest' — the mark scheme requires these qualifiers.
Things to Be Careful About
- The phrase 'ratio of atoms' must be present; saying 'ratio of elements' is not quite right since elements are types of atoms, not countable entities in a molecule.
Cyclopentane, , has four cyclic structural isomers. One of these isomers is C, shown in Fig. 3.1.
Complete Fig. 3.1 to show two other cyclic structural isomers of .
Answer
Two of the following cyclic structural isomers of C₅H₁₀ (other than cyclopentane and 1,1-dimethylcyclopropane which are already shown):
- Methylcyclobutane — a four-membered ring with one methyl substituent.
- 1,2-Dimethylcyclopropane — a three-membered ring with methyl groups on adjacent carbons.
- Ethylcyclopropane — a three-membered ring with an ethyl substituent.
Methylcyclobutane and 1,2-dimethylcyclopropane (or ethylcyclopropane)
Background Concept
Structural isomers have the same molecular formula but different connectivity of atoms. For cyclic compounds with formula C₅H₁₀, the degree of unsaturation is 1 (either one ring or one double bond). Since the question specifies cyclic isomers, all structures must contain a ring. The ring can be 5-membered (cyclopentane), 4-membered (methylcyclobutane), or 3-membered (dimethylcyclopropanes and ethylcyclopropane).
Understanding the Question
The question asks for two cyclic structural isomers of C₅H₁₀ to be drawn in the blank boxes of Fig. 3.1. Cyclopentane and 1,1-dimethylcyclopropane (compound C) are already shown, so the candidate must provide two from the remaining three possibilities.
Approach
Systematically reduce the ring size from 5 → 4 → 3, distributing the remaining carbons as substituents:
- 5-ring: cyclopentane (given)
- 4-ring: methylcyclobutane (one methyl on the ring)
- 3-ring: ethylcyclopropane (one ethyl on the ring), 1,1-dimethylcyclopropane (given as C), 1,2-dimethylcyclopropane (methyls on adjacent carbons)
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Cyclopentane uses all 5 carbons in the ring — given.
- Methylcyclobutane: 4 carbons in ring + 1 methyl = C₅H₁₀. Valid cyclic isomer.
- Ethylcyclopropane: 3 carbons in ring + 2 carbons as ethyl = C₅H₁₀. Valid.
- 1,1-Dimethylcyclopropane: 3 + 1 + 1 = C₅H₁₀. Given as C.
- 1,2-Dimethylcyclopropane: 3 + 1 + 1 = C₅H₁₀. Valid.
Any two of methylcyclobutane, ethylcyclopropane, or 1,2-dimethylcyclopropane earn full marks.
Key Takeaways
- When enumerating cyclic isomers, vary ring size first, then substituent position.
- All structures must have exactly 5 carbons and 10 hydrogens with one ring (degree of unsaturation = 1).
- Skeletal (line-angle) notation is acceptable and expected.
Common Mistakes
- Drawing an acyclic alkene (e.g. pent-1-ene) — the question specifies cyclic isomers.
- Drawing 1,1-dimethylcyclopropane again (already given as C).
- Incorrect hydrogen count (e.g. forgetting that each ring carbon in a saturated ring has two H's unless substituted).
Things to Be Careful About
- Ensure the total carbon count is exactly 5 in each structure.
- Use proper skeletal notation: each vertex and line-end is a carbon; hydrogens on carbon are implied.
- 1,2-dimethylcyclopropane and 1,1-dimethylcyclopropane are different structural isomers (not stereoisomers of each other).
Cyclopentane reacts with in the presence of ultraviolet light to form .
The reaction is initiated by the bond fission of .
State the type of bond fission shown in the initiation step.
Answer
Homolytic (fission).
Homolytic
Background Concept
Bond fission can be homolytic or heterolytic. In homolytic fission, the bonding pair of electrons is split equally between the two fragments, producing radicals (species with unpaired electrons). In heterolytic fission, both electrons go to one fragment, producing ions. Free-radical substitution is initiated by homolytic fission of a halogen-halogen bond under UV light, because the energy of a UV photon is sufficient to break the Cl–Cl bond symmetrically.
Understanding the Question
The question states that the reaction is initiated by bond fission of Cl₂ and asks for the type of fission. This is a one-mark recall question.
Approach
Recognise that UV light causes Cl₂ to split into two chlorine radicals (Cl•), which is the hallmark of homolytic fission.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Cl₂ + UV → 2Cl•. Each chlorine atom takes one electron from the shared pair, giving two neutral radicals. Equal distribution of electrons = homolytic fission.
Key Takeaways
- Homolytic fission → radicals (fish-hook/curly arrows showing one electron moving).
- Heterolytic fission → ions (full curly arrows showing both electrons moving).
- Free-radical mechanisms always begin with homolytic fission.
Common Mistakes
- Writing 'heterolytic' — this would produce Cl⁺ and Cl⁻, which is not what happens under UV.
- Writing 'ionic' or 'polar' — these relate to heterolytic fission.
Things to Be Careful About
- The answer must be the word 'homolytic'; 'homolytic bond fission' or 'homolysis' are also acceptable.
Complete the equations to show the two propagation steps that follow the initiation step.
propagation 1:
propagation 2:
Answer
Propagation 1:
Propagation 2:
Propagation 1: C₅H₁₀ + Cl• → C₅H₉• + HCl; Propagation 2: C₅H₉• + Cl₂ → C₅H₉Cl + Cl•
Background Concept
Free-radical substitution proceeds via a chain mechanism with three stages: initiation (homolytic fission of Cl₂ to give Cl•), propagation (two steps that consume one radical and regenerate another, sustaining the chain), and termination (two radicals combine to form a stable molecule). In the first propagation step, a chlorine radical abstracts a hydrogen atom from the alkane/cycloalkane, forming HCl and a carbon-centred radical. In the second propagation step, the carbon radical reacts with a Cl₂ molecule, forming the chloro-substituted product and regenerating a chlorine radical.
Understanding the Question
The question provides the skeleton of both propagation equations with blanks to fill in. The starting material is cyclopentane (C₅H₁₀) and the product is C₅H₉Cl. The candidate must identify the missing reactant and product species in each step.
Approach
Step 1: Cl• abstracts H from C₅H₁₀, giving C₅H₉• and HCl.
Step 2: C₅H₉• attacks Cl₂, giving C₅H₉Cl and regenerating Cl•.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Propagation 1: The chlorine radical (Cl•) is the attacking species (from initiation). It removes a hydrogen atom from cyclopentane, producing a cyclopentyl radical (C₅H₉•) and HCl. The equation balances: C₅H₁₀ + Cl• → C₅H₉• + HCl.
Propagation 2: The cyclopentyl radical (C₅H₉•) reacts with a chlorine molecule (Cl₂), abstracting one chlorine atom to form chlorocyclopentane (C₅H₉Cl) and releasing a new chlorine radical (Cl•). This regenerates the chain carrier. Equation: C₅H₉• + Cl₂ → C₅H₉Cl + Cl•.
Note that adding propagation 1 and 2 gives the overall reaction: C₅H₁₀ + Cl₂ → C₅H₉Cl + HCl, confirming the mechanism is consistent.
Key Takeaways
- Propagation steps always consume one radical and produce one radical (chain-carrying).
- The first propagation step is hydrogen abstraction; the second is halogen transfer.
- The two propagation steps together give the net substitution reaction.
Common Mistakes
- Writing Cl₂ instead of Cl• in propagation 1.
- Writing H₂ instead of HCl as the by-product of propagation 1.
- Forgetting the radical dot (•) on C₅H₉• or Cl•.
- Writing the product of propagation 2 as just C₅H₉Cl without the regenerated Cl•.
Things to Be Careful About
- Include the radical dot (•) on all radical species — the mark scheme requires it.
- Ensure both equations are balanced in terms of atoms and charge (all species are neutral).
Answer
Termination.
Termination
Background Concept
A free-radical chain mechanism consists of initiation (radicals are created), propagation (radicals are consumed and regenerated in a cycle), and termination (two radicals combine to form a stable molecule, ending the chain). Termination steps reduce the total number of radicals in the system.
Understanding the Question
The equation C₅H₉• + Cl• → C₅H₉Cl shows two radicals combining to form a stable molecule. The question asks for the name of this step.
Approach
Since two radicals are consumed and no new radical is produced, this is a termination step.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
In propagation, one radical in + one radical out maintains the chain. Here, two radicals (C₅H₉• and Cl•) combine to give one stable molecule (C₅H₉Cl) with no radical product. The chain is ended — this is termination.
Key Takeaways
- Termination: radical + radical → stable molecule (net loss of radicals).
- Other possible termination steps in this reaction: Cl• + Cl• → Cl₂, and C₅H₉• + C₅H₉• → C₁₀H₁₈.
Common Mistakes
- Calling it 'propagation' — propagation regenerates a radical; termination does not.
- Calling it 'initiation' — initiation creates radicals from non-radical species.
Things to Be Careful About
- The answer is simply 'termination'; 'termination step' is also acceptable.
Fig. 3.2 shows a reaction cycle involving cyclopentane, cyclopentene and .
Answer
HCl
HCl
Background Concept
Reaction 3 in the cycle converts cyclopentene (an alkene with a C=C double bond) directly to chlorocyclopentane (a haloalkane). This is an electrophilic addition reaction. Adding HX across the double bond of an alkene gives a halogenoalkane. The reagent is hydrogen chloride (HCl), which adds across the C=C bond: the H adds to one carbon and Cl to the other.
Understanding the Question
The question asks for a suitable reagent that converts cyclopentene to chlorocyclopentane in a single step (reaction 3 in the Hess cycle).
Approach
Identify what is being added: the product has one more H and one more Cl than the reactant (C₅H₈ → CH₉Cl), so HCl is added across the double bond.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Cyclopentene is C₅H₈; chlorocyclopentane is C₅H₉Cl. The difference is +H and +Cl, i.e. HCl has been added. Electrophilic addition of HCl to the C=C double bond of cyclopentene gives chlorocyclopentane.
Key Takeaways
- Alkene + HX → halogenoalkane (electrophilic addition).
- The reagent must supply both the H and the halogen that appear in the product relative to the reactant.
Common Mistakes
- Writing Cl₂ — that would give a dichloro compound (addition of two Cl atoms), not chlorocyclopentane.
- Writing NaCl or H₂SO₄ — these do not add across a double bond.
Things to Be Careful About
- The mark scheme accepts 'HCl' or 'HCl(g)' or 'hydrogen chloride'. Do not write 'HCl(aq)' as aqueous HCl is less commonly used for this reaction, though it may still be accepted.
Use the data in Fig. 3.2 and in Table 3.1 to calculate the enthalpy change of reaction 2, .
Table 3.1
| compound | enthalpy change of combustion, / |
|---|---|
| cyclopentane | –3292 |
| cyclopentene | –3115 |
| –286 |
= ...........................................
Working
Using Hess's law for reaction 1 (cyclopentene + H₂ → cyclopentane):
From the cycle: reaction 1 + reaction 2 = reaction 3 (cyclopentene → cyclopentane → chlorocyclopentane is the same overall as cyclopentene → chlorocyclopentane).
Answer
+56 kJ mol⁻¹
Background Concept
Hess's law states that the total enthalpy change for a reaction is independent of the pathway taken, provided the initial and final conditions are the same. When enthalpy changes of combustion are given, the enthalpy of reaction can be found using: ΔH_r = ΣΔH_c(reactants) − ΣΔH_c(products). This works because combustion takes all substances to the same final products (CO₂ and H₂O), so the difference in combustion enthalpies gives the reaction enthalpy.
Understanding the Question
The reaction cycle shows:
- Reaction 1: cyclopentene + H₂ → cyclopentane (ΔH₁, unknown)
- Reaction 2: cyclopentane + Cl₂ → chlorocyclopentane (ΔH₂, to find)
- Reaction 3: cyclopentene + HCl → chlorocyclopentane (ΔH₃ = −53 kJ mol⁻¹)
Combustion data are given for cyclopentane, cyclopentene, and H₂.
Approach
Step 1: Calculate ΔH₁ using combustion data (reactants − products convention).
Step 2: Use the cycle relationship ΔH₁ + ΔH₂ = ΔH₃ to find ΔH₂.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Finding ΔH₁:
Reaction 1: cyclopentene + H₂ → cyclopentane
Using Hess's law with combustion data: ΔH₁ = [ΔH_c(cyclopentene) + ΔH_c(H₂)] − [ΔH_c(cyclopentane)]
= [(−3115) + (−286)] − (−3292)
= −3401 + 3292
= −109 kJ mol⁻¹
Finding ΔH₂:
From the cycle, going from cyclopentene to chlorocyclopentane via cyclopentane (reactions 1 then 2) gives the same overall change as reaction 3 directly.
Therefore: ΔH₁ + ΔH₂ = ΔH₃
−109 + ΔH₂ = −53
ΔH₂ = −53 + 109 = +56 kJ mol⁻¹
The positive value makes sense: free-radical substitution of a C–H bond by Cl is only mildly endothermic overall (or slightly exothermic depending on conditions), but here the cycle gives +56 kJ mol⁻¹.
Key Takeaways
- When using combustion data in a Hess cycle: ΔH_r = ΣΔH_c(reactants) − ΣΔH_c(products).
- In a triangular cycle, the sum of enthalpy changes around any closed path is zero, or equivalently, the direct route equals the sum of the indirect routes.
- Always track signs carefully: ΔH_c values are negative (exothermic).
Common Mistakes
- Reversing the reactants/products order: writing ΔH₁ = ΔH_c(cyclopentane) − ΔH_c(cyclopentene) − ΔH_c(H₂) = +3292 + 3115 + 286 (wrong sign convention).
- Forgetting that ΔH_c of H₂ is −286 (it is given in the table).
- Sign error in the final step: ΔH₂ = ΔH₃ − ΔH₁ = −53 − (−109) = +56, not −162.
Things to Be Careful About
- The mark scheme awards M1 for correctly calculating ΔH₁ = −109 kJ mol⁻¹ and M2 for correctly finding ΔH₂ = +56 kJ mol⁻¹. Error carried forward is possible: if ΔH₁ is wrong but used consistently, M2 may still be awarded.
Cyclopentene, , reacts with hot concentrated acidified to form compound W, .
Answer
Hot concentrated acidified KMnO₄ cleaves the C=C bond of cyclopentene, oxidising both carbons of the former double bond to carboxylic acid groups. The product W is pentanedioic acid (glutaric acid), HOOC–CH₂–CH₂–CH₂–COOH.
Pentanedioic acid (glutaric acid): HOOCCH₂CH₂CH₂COOH
Background Concept
Oxidative cleavage of alkenes by hot concentrated acidified KMnO₄ breaks the C=C double bond completely. Each carbon of the former double bond is oxidised: if it bears a hydrogen, it becomes a carboxylic acid group (–COOH); if it bears two alkyl groups (no H), it becomes a ketone. In a cyclic alkene, cleavage opens the ring and produces a dicarboxylic acid (since both double-bond carbons in cyclopentene each have one H).
Understanding the Question
Cyclopentene (C₅H₈) reacts with hot concentrated acidified KMnO₄ to give W (C₅H₈O₄). The molecular formula shows 4 oxygen atoms added — consistent with two –COOH groups (each contributing 2 O atoms). The ring must have opened.
Approach
- Identify that C₅H₈O₄ with 4 oxygens and the reaction conditions point to a dicarboxylic acid.
- Count carbons: 5 carbons in a chain with –COOH at each end gives pentanedioic acid.
- Draw the structure showing all atoms and bonds.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Cyclopentene has the structure: a five-membered ring with one C=C bond. The two carbons of the double bond each have one H attached. Oxidative cleavage breaks the C=C and converts each =CH– to –COOH. The remaining three CH₂ groups form the chain between the two carboxyl groups.
Product: HOOC–CH₂–CH₂–CH₂–COOH (pentanedioic acid / glutaric acid), molecular formula C₅H₈O₄. ✓
Key Takeaways
- Hot concentrated KMnO₄ (or hot concentrated acidified dichromate) cleaves C=C to give carbonyl/carboxyl products.
- Cyclic alkenes give dicarboxylic acids upon oxidative cleavage.
- The molecular formula is a useful check: C₅H₈ + 4[O] → C₅H₈O₄ (two –COOH groups added, ring opened).
Common Mistakes
- Drawing a diol (from cold dilute KMnO₄) instead of the cleavage product.
- Drawing a ketone or aldehyde instead of carboxylic acids.
- Incorrect carbon count in the chain (e.g. drawing butanedioic acid which has only 4 carbons).
Things to Be Careful About
- Show all atoms and bonds in the displayed formula (the mark scheme expects a full structural drawing).
- Ensure the chain has exactly 5 carbons: 2 in the –COOH groups and 3 in the –CH₂–CH₂–CH₂– bridge.
The infrared spectrum of W is shown in Fig. 3.3.
Identify two absorptions in the infrared spectrum of W that would not be present in the infrared spectrum of cyclopentene.
- Write 1 or 2 on Fig. 3.3 against each of these two absorptions.
- Complete Table 3.2 to show which bond is responsible for each absorption that you have identified in Fig. 3.3.
Table 3.2
| absorption | 1 | 2 |
|---|---|---|
| bond responsible |
Table 3.3
| bond | functional groups containing the bond | characteristic infrared absorption range (in wavenumbers) / |
|---|---|---|
| C–O | hydroxy, ester | 1040–1300 |
| C=C | aromatic compound, alkene | 1500–1680 |
| C=O | amide carbonyl, carboxyl ester | 1640–1690 1670–1740 1710–1750 |
| CN | nitrile | 2200–2250 |
| C–H | alkane | 2850–2950 |
| N–H | amine, amide | 3300–3500 |
| O–H | carboxyl hydroxy | 2500–3000 3200–3650 |
Answer
Absorption 1: broad peak at approximately 2500–3000 cm⁻¹ — O–H bond (in carboxylic acid).
Absorption 2: strong peak at approximately 1720 cm⁻¹ — C=O bond (in carboxylic acid).
These absorptions are present in W (pentanedioic acid) but absent in cyclopentene (which has no O–H or C=O bonds).
1: O–H (around 2500–3000 cm⁻¹); 2: C=O (around 1720 cm⁻¹)
Background Concept
Infrared spectroscopy identifies functional groups by measuring the wavenumbers at which bonds absorb IR radiation (causing stretching or bending vibrations). Each bond type absorbs in a characteristic range. When comparing the spectrum of a product to that of a reactant, new absorptions indicate bonds present in the product but absent in the reactant. Cyclopentene contains only C–H and C=C bonds. Pentanedioic acid additionally contains O–H (carboxylic acid) and C=O (carbonyl) bonds.
Understanding the Question
The candidate must identify two absorptions in the IR spectrum of W (Fig. 3.3) that would NOT appear in the IR spectrum of cyclopentene, and state the bond responsible for each. From the data table, the relevant absorptions for a carboxylic acid are: O–H (2500–3000 cm⁻¹, broad) and C=O (1670–1740 cm⁻¹, strong and sharp).
Approach
- Identify the functional groups in W that are absent in cyclopentene: –COOH groups (containing O–H and C=O).
- Locate the corresponding absorptions on the spectrum: a broad trough centred around 2500–3000 cm⁻¹ (O–H of carboxylic acid) and a sharp strong peak near 1720 cm⁻¹ (C=O).
- Label these on Fig. 3.3 and complete the table.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Cyclopentene has C–H (2850–2950 cm⁻¹) and C=C (1500–1680 cm⁻¹) absorptions. It has no O–H or C=O.
W (pentanedioic acid) has two –COOH groups, each containing:
- An O–H bond: absorbs broadly at 2500–3000 cm⁻¹ (the broad O–H of a carboxylic acid overlaps with and extends below the C–H region, producing the very broad absorption seen in Fig. 3.3 centred around 3000 cm⁻¹).
- A C=O bond: absorbs strongly and sharply at approximately 1720 cm⁻¹ (within the 1670–1740 range for carboxylic acid carbonyl).
These two absorptions are new relative to cyclopentene's spectrum.
Key Takeaways
- Carboxylic acid O–H is very broad (2500–3000 cm⁻¹), distinct from the narrower alcohol O–H (3200–3650 cm⁻¹).
- The C=O stretch of a carboxylic acid appears around 1710–1740 cm⁻¹.
- When asked for absorptions 'not present in the reactant', focus on bonds unique to the product's functional groups.
Common Mistakes
- Identifying C–H (present in both cyclopentene and W) — this is not a new absorption.
- Identifying C=C — this is present in cyclopentene but absent in W (so it would be an absorption present in cyclopentene but not W, the reverse of what is asked).
- Labelling the wrong peak on the spectrum (e.g. pointing to a fingerprint region peak).
Things to Be Careful About
- The O–H of a carboxylic acid is very broad and centred around 3000 cm⁻¹, overlapping the C–H region. The mark scheme accepts approximately 3000 cm⁻¹ for the O–H label.
- The C=O peak is sharp and strong, around 1720 cm⁻¹. Do not confuse it with the C=C absorption of cyclopentene (1500–1680 cm⁻¹).
- The question asks for the bond responsible, not the functional group name, so write 'O–H' and 'C=O' (or 'C=O (carbonyl)').
Fig. 4.1 shows a possible synthesis of propene, .
Answer
reduction
reduction
Background Concept
Carboxylic acids can be reduced to primary alcohols using a strong reducing agent such as lithium aluminium hydride () in dry ether, followed by acidification. This is a reduction reaction because the carbon atom gains bonds to hydrogen and loses a bond to oxygen, resulting in a decrease in its oxidation state.
Understanding the Question
The question asks for the type of reaction that converts propanoic acid () to propan-1-ol () in reaction 1. The functional group changes from a carboxylic acid () to a primary alcohol ().
Approach
Compare the functional groups of the reactant and product. A carboxylic acid gaining hydrogen (and losing oxygen) to form an alcohol is a reduction.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
The conversion of a carboxylic acid to a primary alcohol involves the addition of hydrogen across the bond (conceptually) and the removal of oxygen. In organic chemistry, gaining bonds to hydrogen or losing bonds to oxygen is classified as reduction. Therefore, reaction 1 is a reduction.
Key Takeaways
Carboxylic acids are reduced to primary alcohols. Recognising this transformation allows quick identification of the reaction type as reduction.
Common Mistakes
Students sometimes confuse this with oxidation (which would convert an alcohol to a carboxylic acid) or substitution. Always check the direction of the arrow and the functional groups involved.
Things to Be Careful About
Ensure the answer is simply "reduction" as requested. Do not overcomplicate with reagent details unless asked.
Answer
(or or )
OR KCl (or NaCl) and conc. (or conc. )
PCl5 (or PCl3 or SOCl2) OR KCl/NaCl and conc. H2SO4
Background Concept
Primary alcohols can be converted to chloroalkanes by reacting them with reagents that provide a chloride ion or act as a chlorinating agent. Common reagents include phosphorus pentachloride (), phosphorus trichloride (), and thionyl chloride (). Alternatively, concentrated hydrochloric acid or chloride salts (like KCl or NaCl) in the presence of concentrated sulfuric acid () or concentrated phosphoric acid () can be used to generate in situ, which then reacts with the alcohol.
Understanding the Question
The question asks for a suitable reagent to convert propan-1-ol () to 1-chloropropane () in reaction 2.
Approach
Recall the standard reagents used for the substitution of the group in alcohols with a group.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
To convert a primary alcohol to a chloroalkane, you can use:
- (solid, reacts vigorously at room temperature)
- (liquid, requires warming)
- (thionyl chloride, produces gaseous by-products making purification easy)
- A chloride salt (KCl or NaCl) with concentrated or concentrated (the acid generates which then reacts with the alcohol).
Any of these acceptable combinations will score the mark.
Key Takeaways
Know the multiple reagent options for converting alcohols to chloroalkanes. , , and are the most direct, while chloride salts require a strong acid catalyst.
Common Mistakes
- Writing just "HCl" without specifying concentrated or the presence of a chloride salt/acid.
- Using reagents suitable for secondary/tertiary alcohols (like /ZnCl Lucas reagent) without considering that primary alcohols react very slowly with them.
Things to Be Careful About
If using chloride salts (KCl/NaCl), you MUST include the concentrated acid ( or ). Just writing "KCl" is not sufficient.
Reaction 3 is an elimination reaction.
Write an equation for this reaction and identify the solvent and conditions used.
equation ............................................................................................................................
solvent and conditions .......................................................................................................
Answer
equation:
solvent and conditions: ethanol (solvent) and heat (or reflux)
Equation: C2H5CH2Cl + NaOH -> C3H6 + H2O + NaCl; Solvent: ethanol; Conditions: heat/reflux
Background Concept
Halogenoalkanes can undergo two competing reactions with hydroxide ions (): nucleophilic substitution (forming alcohols) and elimination (forming alkenes). The pathway taken depends heavily on the solvent and temperature.
- Substitution is favoured in aqueous NaOH/KOH and at lower temperatures.
- Elimination is favoured in ethanolic (alcoholic) NaOH/KOH and at high temperatures (reflux).
In elimination, the acts as a base, removing a proton () from a -carbon (the carbon adjacent to the one holding the halogen), while the halide ion leaves, forming a double bond.
Understanding the Question
Reaction 3 converts 1-chloropropane () to propene () using NaOH. The question states this is an elimination reaction and asks for the balanced equation and the specific solvent and conditions required.
Approach
Write the balanced chemical equation for the elimination of HCl from 1-chloropropane to form propene. Then, specify the solvent (ethanol) and conditions (heat/reflux) that promote elimination over substitution.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Equation:
The reactant is (or ) and NaOH. The products are propene (), water (), and sodium chloride ().
(Note: State symbols are often not required for this specific mark unless specified, but the balancing must be correct.)
Solvent and Conditions:
To ensure elimination occurs rather than substitution (which would give propan-1-ol), the NaOH must be dissolved in ethanol (not water), and the mixture must be heated, typically under reflux.
Key Takeaways
The solvent is the key discriminator between substitution and elimination for halogenoalkanes with NaOH/KOH. Ethanol + heat = elimination; Water = substitution.
Common Mistakes
- Writing the equation for substitution () instead of elimination.
- Forgetting to include NaCl and HO as products.
- Specifying "aqueous NaOH" or "water" as the solvent, which would favour substitution.
Things to Be Careful About
Ensure the equation is balanced. The mark scheme accepts the molecular formula representation. Make sure to explicitly state "ethanol" as the solvent, not just "alcohol" (though "alcohol" is sometimes accepted, "ethanol" is precise).
can be directly converted to .
Suggest the reagent and conditions for this conversion.
Answer
conc. (or conc. ) OR AND heat
conc. H2SO4 (or conc. H3PO4) OR Al2O3 and heat
Background Concept
Alcohols can be dehydrated to form alkenes by removing a molecule of water. This is an elimination reaction (specifically, a dehydration).
- Acid-catalysed dehydration: Concentrated sulfuric acid () or concentrated phosphoric acid () is used as a catalyst and dehydrating agent. The reaction requires heating (typically around 170°C for primary alcohols with ).
- Vapor-phase dehydration: Passing alcohol vapour over a heated catalyst such as aluminium oxide () at high temperatures (around 300-400°C).
Understanding the Question
The question asks for the reagent and conditions to directly convert propan-1-ol () to propene (). This is a dehydration reaction.
Approach
Recall the standard reagents and conditions for the dehydration of alcohols to alkenes.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
To dehydrate a primary alcohol to an alkene:
- Use concentrated or concentrated with heat.
- Alternatively, use (aluminium oxide) as a catalyst with heat.
Any of these combinations is acceptable.
Key Takeaways
Dehydration of alcohols to alkenes requires an acid catalyst (conc. or ) with heat, or a solid catalyst like with heat.
Common Mistakes
- Writing "dilute " — dilute acid does not cause dehydration; it might be used for hydration of alkenes (the reverse reaction).
- Forgetting to include "heat" as a condition.
Things to Be Careful About
Specify "concentrated" if writing an acid. If writing , remember to include "heat" as the condition.
Under suitable conditions, propene polymerises to form poly(propene).
Poly(propene) exhibits stereoisomerism.
Answer
addition
addition
Background Concept
Alkenes contain a double bond. Under suitable conditions (catalyst, heat, pressure), the bond breaks and the monomers add together to form a long-chain polymer without the loss of any small molecules. This is called addition polymerisation.
Understanding the Question
The question asks for the type of polymerisation that forms poly(propene) from propene monomers.
Approach
Propene is an alkene. Alkenes undergo addition polymerisation to form polymers like poly(ethene), poly(propene), etc.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Since propene () has a double bond that opens up to link with other monomers, and no atoms are lost in the process, the reaction is addition polymerisation.
Key Takeaways
All alkenes undergo addition polymerisation to form poly(alkenes).
Common Mistakes
- Writing "condensation" — condensation polymerisation involves two different functional groups (e.g., diol + dicarboxylic acid) and the loss of a small molecule like water.
Things to Be Careful About
Just write "addition". Do not write "addition polymerisation" unless asked for the full name, though "addition" is the key mark.
Answer
(molecules that have the) same structural formula (and same molecular formula)
but different 3D / spatial arrangement of atoms / groups
Same structural formula but different 3D/spatial arrangement of atoms
Background Concept
Isomers are molecules with the same molecular formula but different arrangements of atoms. They are divided into two main categories:
- Structural isomers: Different structural formulae (different connectivity of atoms). Examples include chain, position, and functional group isomers.
- Stereoisomers: Same structural formula (same connectivity) but different spatial arrangements of atoms. This includes geometric (cis/trans or E/Z) isomerism and optical isomerism (enantiomers).
Understanding the Question
The question asks for a definition of stereoisomerism.
Approach
Provide the standard IUPAC-style definition: same structural formula (and molecular formula) but different spatial arrangement.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Stereoisomerism requires:
- The same molecular formula.
- The same structural formula (atoms are connected in the same order).
- A different 3D or spatial arrangement of those atoms or groups in space.
Key Takeaways
Stereoisomers have identical connectivity but differ in how the atoms are oriented in 3D space.
Common Mistakes
- Saying "same molecular formula but different structural formula" — that is structural isomerism.
- Forgetting to mention "spatial" or "3D" arrangement.
Things to Be Careful About
The definition must include both "same structural formula" and "different spatial arrangement". Marking schemes often award one mark for each part.
Draw a section of poly(propene), showing two repeat units.
Use your diagram to identify the type of stereoisomerism shown by poly(propene). Explain your answer.
Answer
Type of stereoisomerism: optical isomerism
Explanation: The carbon atom bonded to the methyl group has four different groups attached to it (it is a chiral centre / asymmetric carbon).
Optical isomerism; the methylated carbon has four different groups attached
Background Concept
Poly(propene) is formed from propene monomers (). The repeat unit is . In the polymer chain, the carbon atom bearing the methyl group is bonded to:
- A hydrogen atom ()
- A methyl group ()
- A group (part of the chain towards one end)
- A group (part of the chain towards the other end)
Because the two polymer chain segments are different (one ends in , the other in ), this carbon atom is a chiral centre (asymmetric carbon). Polymers with chiral centres along the backbone can exhibit optical isomerism (specifically, isotactic, syndiotactic, and atactic forms are stereoisomers based on the arrangement of these chiral centres).
Understanding the Question
The question asks to:
- Draw a section of poly(propene) showing two repeat units (displayed formula showing all atoms and bonds).
- Identify the type of stereoisomerism.
- Explain why using the diagram.
Approach
Draw the displayed formula for two repeat units: . Ensure bonds extend to the left and right. Identify that the carbons with methyl groups are chiral centres, leading to optical isomerism.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Drawing:
The repeat unit of poly(propene) is . Two repeat units would be:
In a displayed formula, draw the carbon backbone horizontally. Attach H atoms and the groups to the appropriate carbons. Single bonds must extend from the ends to show the chain continues.
Identification:
The type of stereoisomerism is optical isomerism (or enantiomerism, though "optical" is the standard term here).
Explanation:
Look at one of the carbon atoms bonded to the methyl group (the carbon in the repeat unit). It is bonded to:
- (the rest of the chain in one direction)
- (the rest of the chain in the other direction)
These four groups are all different. Therefore, the carbon is a chiral centre (asymmetric carbon), which is the requirement for optical isomerism.
Key Takeaways
Polymers like poly(propene) have chiral centres along the backbone due to the substituent on every other carbon. This leads to stereoisomerism (optical/tacticity). Always check the four groups attached to the carbon in question.
Common Mistakes
- Drawing a skeletal formula instead of a displayed formula (the question asks to "draw a section... showing two repeat units" and the mark scheme implies a displayed formula to show the groups clearly).
- Forgetting to extend bonds at the ends of the drawn section.
- Identifying the isomerism as "geometric" or "cis/trans" — there is no restricted rotation here that gives cis/trans in the main chain; the chirality is at the carbon with the methyl group.
- Failing to list all four different groups or simply saying "it has 4 different groups" without referencing the specific carbon.
Things to Be Careful About
The diagram must be a displayed formula showing all atoms and bonds for the two repeat units. The explanation must clearly state that the carbon with the methyl group has four different groups attached.
Answer
- non-biodegradability (they persist in the environment / do not break down)
- harmful combustion products (if burned, they release toxic gases / CO / dioxins / contribute to global warming / require energy to burn)
Non-biodegradable; harmful combustion products
Background Concept
Poly(alkene)s like poly(propene) and poly(ethene) are widely used but pose significant disposal challenges:
- Non-biodegradability: They are made of strong and bonds that are not easily broken down by microorganisms. They persist in landfills and the environment for hundreds of years, contributing to litter and microplastic pollution.
- Combustion issues: If incinerated, they release large amounts of (a greenhouse gas) and potentially harmful/toxic gases (like , dioxins, or furans if combustion is incomplete or if additives are present). They also require energy to burn.
- Recycling difficulties: Separating different types of polymers is expensive and time-consuming.
Understanding the Question
The question asks for two difficulties associated with the disposal of poly(propene).
Approach
State two well-known environmental or practical problems with disposing of poly(alkene)s.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
- Non-biodegradability: Poly(propene) is chemically inert and resistant to biological degradation. It accumulates in landfills and oceans.
- Harmful combustion products: Burning poly(propene) releases (contributing to climate change) and potentially toxic gases if combustion is incomplete. Alternatively, one could mention the energy required for incineration or the difficulty/cost of recycling.
Key Takeaways
Poly(alkene)s are problematic because they do not biodegrade and their combustion can produce harmful emissions.
Common Mistakes
- Writing "human error" or "not accurate" — these are not specific to poly(propene) disposal.
- Writing "it takes up space" — while true, "non-biodegradability" or "accumulation in landfills" is the chemically/environmentally precise answer expected.
Things to Be Careful About
Be specific. "Non-biodegradable" is a key term. "Harmful combustion products" is a key phrase. Avoid vague answers.
Under different conditions, two molecules of propene can combine to form compounds X and Y.
Answer
2,3-dimethylbut-1-ene
2,3-dimethylbut-1-ene
Background Concept
Naming alkenes using IUPAC rules:
- Find the longest carbon chain containing the double bond. This is the parent chain.
- Number the chain from the end closest to the double bond to give the the lowest possible locant.
- Identify and name substituents (alkyl groups, halogens, etc.) and assign them locants based on the numbering.
- Assemble the name: substituents (in alphabetical order) + parent chain name + double bond locant + "ene".
Understanding the Question
Fig 4.4 shows the skeletal structure of compound X. We need to name it.
Approach
Interpret the skeletal structure: count the longest chain containing the double bond, number it, identify substituents, and construct the name.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Looking at compound X:
- The longest chain containing the double bond has 4 carbons (butene).
- Numbering from the end with the double bond: .
- At , there is a methyl group ().
- At , there is a methyl group ().
- The double bond starts at .
So the name is 2,3-dimethylbut-1-ene.
Key Takeaways
Always number the chain to give the functional group (double bond) the lowest number, even if it means substituents get higher numbers.
Common Mistakes
- Numbering from the wrong end (giving 3,4-dimethylbut-3-ene, which is incorrect).
- Missing a methyl group or miscounting the chain length.
Things to Be Careful About
Ensure the locant for the double bond is included (but-1-ene, not just butene, though older nomenclature might accept but-1-ene as the only option, modern IUPAC requires it). The name is 2,3-dimethylbut-1-ene.
Fig. 4.2 shows the mass spectrum of either compound X or compound Y.
Identify which of X and Y gives this mass spectrum.
Give one reason for your answer, referring to the fragmentation pattern.
Answer
The spectrum is of X (2,3-dimethylbut-1-ene).
Reason: The peak at m/e = 41 corresponds to the ion (or ), which is formed by the cleavage of X. (Alternatively: the peak at 43 is / ; or X would not have a significant peak at 54/57 or 42).
Working
X () fragments to give:
- at m/z 41 ()
- at m/z 43 ()
Y () would not produce a significant peak at 41.
Answer
X; peak at 41 is /
X; peak at 41 is [CH2=CCH3]+ or C3H5+
Background Concept
In mass spectrometry, molecular ions fragment into characteristic ions. The fragmentation pattern depends on the stability of the resulting carbocations and the ease of bond cleavage. Allylic and branched carbocations are particularly stable.
- For X (2,3-dimethylbut-1-ene): . Cleavage between and gives:
- (m/z = 12+2+12+12+3 = 41, ) — an allylic cation, very stable.
- (m/z = 12+1+12+3+12+3 = 43, ) — a secondary carbocation, stable.
- For Y (2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene): . Cleavage would give (m/z 43) or (m/z 57). It would NOT produce a significant peak at m/z 41 () because there is no group to form that specific allylic cation easily.
Understanding the Question
The mass spectrum shows a large peak at m/z = 41 (100% relative abundance) and a large peak at m/z = 43 (90%). We must identify whether this is X or Y and give a reason based on fragmentation.
Approach
Calculate the m/z values for likely fragments of X and Y and match them to the spectrum. The peak at 41 is the key discriminator.
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Fragmentation of X (2,3-dimethylbut-1-ene):
Structure:
- Break the bond:
- Left fragment: -> -> m/z = . This is an allylic carbocation, highly stable, so it will be a major peak (base peak).
- Right fragment: -> -> m/z = . This is a secondary carbocation, also stable.
- The spectrum shows peaks at 41 and 43, which matches X perfectly.
Fragmentation of Y (2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene):
Structure:
- Breaking a bond next to the double bond gives (m/z 43) or (m/z 57).
- It does NOT have a group, so it cannot easily form the (m/z 41) allylic cation in high abundance.
- Therefore, the spectrum with a base peak at 41 must be X.
Key Takeaways
Fragmentation patterns are unique to molecular structure. Allylic cleavage producing stable allylic carbocations (like m/z 41 for ) is a key identifier for terminal alkenes with branching.
Common Mistakes
- Calculating the m/z incorrectly (e.g., forgetting the mass of hydrogen or carbon).
- Identifying the wrong fragment for m/z 41 (it is , not which is 29).
- Not linking the fragment to the specific structure (must mention or ).
Things to Be Careful About
The reason must refer to the specific fragment at m/z = 41 (or the absence of certain peaks in Y). Simply saying "X has a peak at 41" is not enough; you must explain WHAT the peak at 41 is (the ion formula).
The molecular ion peak in the spectrum in Fig. 4.2 has relative abundance 34.7.
Calculate the relative abundance of the peak in this spectrum.
Working
The molecular formula of X (and Y) is . There are 6 carbon atoms.
The natural abundance of is 1.1% relative to .
The relative abundance of the peak is given by:
Alternatively:
Answer
2.29
2.29
Background Concept
In mass spectrometry, the peak is primarily caused by the presence of the isotope. Carbon has two stable isotopes: (abundance ~98.9%) and (abundance ~1.1%).
For a molecule with carbon atoms, the probability of having exactly one atom (and the rest ) is approximately . Therefore, the relative abundance of the peak compared to the molecular ion peak is:
where is the number of carbon atoms.
Understanding the Question
The molecular ion peak () has a relative abundance of 34.7. We need to calculate the relative abundance of the peak. The compounds X and Y are both (isomers of hexene / dimethylbutene).
Approach
- Determine the number of carbon atoms in the molecular formula ( -> 6 carbons).
- Use the formula: .
Step-by-Step Reasoning
Molecular formula: Both X and Y are formed from two propene molecules (). So .
Calculation:
Rounding to 3 significant figures (consistent with 34.7): 2.29.
Key Takeaways
The peak relative abundance is directly proportional to the number of carbon atoms. Use the formula: .
Common Mistakes
- Using the wrong number of carbon atoms (e.g., counting hydrogens or total atoms).
- Forgetting to divide by 100 or multiplying incorrectly.
- Not using 1.1% for abundance (sometimes 1.08% is used in advanced contexts, but 1.1% is standard for A-Level).
Things to Be Careful About
Ensure the calculation is: . The result is 2.29. Do not confuse this with the percentage abundance; the question asks for the relative abundance in the spectrum (which is scaled to the base peak = 100). The value 2.29 is correct on that scale.






